Home > Features >

Controversy: Was the right replay shown to decide Tendulkar’s dismissal against Chargers?

Sachin Tendulkar was on the non-strikers end when he was given out

By Nishad Pai Vaidya

Was the wrong footage used in Sunday’s game between Mumbai Indians and Deccan Chargers that ended in the dismissal of Sachin Tendulkar? It would seem so.

Let’s go back and look at the sequence of what exactly happened. When Tendulkar lofted Amit Mishra into the hands of long-on, the on-field umpire called on the third umpire to check whether the bowler had overstepped. This is what I observed. The first replay shown was from the stump camera. From there it wasn’t clear whether Mishra had overstepped as his foot seemed on the line. The second replay they showed was from midwicket. From that angle it looked as if his foot was on the line and there wasn’t anything behind the line. A third angle, from the covers, was considered. However, in this replay you can see Tendulkar standing in the background! My question is: How can a batsman who has faced the delivery be standing at the non-striker’s end?! More importantly, in that particular replay Amit Mishra was comfortably within the limits and hadn’t overstepped. The third umpire ruled the delivery as legal on the basis of the third replay.

Video: Fast forward it to :0:48:18 for the topic under discussion.

Tendulkar lofts the ball towards long-off and is caught by Dale Steyn. The replays are called for. The first replay from the stump camera is inconclusive if the bowler overstepped. The second replay from midwicket suggests that the bowler’s foot is on the line and not behind the line. You can hear commentator Pommie Mbangwa surprised and saying, “Ohh, hold on…” From a third angle it’s evident that its not a no-ball looked, but what you can clearly see Tendulkar at the non- striker’s end (see photo) and not Ambati Rayadu!

The question is not whether it was a no-ball or not. In fact, that is secondary. The biggest question raised is about those handling the footage of the game and the third umpire. It looks as if the wrong replay was shown. The third umpire would naturally look at the line and not consider the background, as he has to decide whether the bowler overstepped or not. However, shouldn’t the third umpire also exercise due care while making such decisions?

This dismissal has raised more than a question and somebody has to answer them. It’s imperative that the team handling the feeds has to provide the correct footage. However, should that not be the case, the third umpire has to be duly empowered.

Technology has been a fairly recent addition to the game of cricket. From the first use of the third umpire in the year 1992, we have moved towards Hawk-Eye, hot spot etc. The third umpire has become even more crucial since the inception of the Umpire Decision Review System (UDRS). However, one cannot rely on technology completely and the third umpire has to do his due diligence. More than that, the team behind the scenes have to ensure they provide the third umpire with the right footage. Clearly, after the controversial dismissal of Tendulkar, the authenticity of the TV replays will not be seen as foolproof any longer.

(Nishad Pai Vaidya, a 20-year-old law student, is a club and college-level cricketer. His teachers always complain, “He knows the stats and facts of cricket more than the subjects we teach him.”)

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 6, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Galle

India tour of England 2014

Aug 7, 2014 (15:30 IST)   at Manchester

South Africa in Zimbabwe, 2014

Aug 9, 2014 (13:30 IST)   at Harare

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 14, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Colombo

India tour of England 2014

Aug 15, 2014 (15:30 IST)   at London

More

India tour of England 2014

Jul 27, 2014  at Southampton

England won by 266 runs

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 24, 2014  at Bulawayo

Afghanistan won by 100 runs

South Africa tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Jul 24, 2014  at Colombo

Match drawn

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 22, 2014  at Bulawayo

Afghanistan won by 2 wkts

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 20, 2014  at Bulawayo

Zimbabwe won by 8 wkts

Photos

India vs England 2014, 3rd Test

Videos

Highlights of Phil Hughes' double ton

5 things you need to know about Graham Thorpe

India vs England 2014, 4th Test at Old Trafford: Ajinkya Rahane needs to play decisive role

10 little-known facts about Sir Frank Worrell

Statistical analysis of Jacques Kallis’s ODI career

Ajinkya Rahane England England vs India England vs India 2014 India India tour of England 2014 India vs England India vs England 2014 Jacques Kallis Jacques Kallis retirement James Anderson Moeen Ali South Africa

Ravindra Jadeja-James Anderson row: An indecisive verdict

India tour of England 2014: Moeen Ali’s six-for excites coach Peter Moores

Cameron White’s ton powers Australia A to 274/5 against India A in Quadrangular final

Perth Scorechers eye Graeme Smith for Big Bash League 2014-15

Jesse Ryder: I have done stuffs which I shouldn’t have

India A vs Australia A 2014, Final: Last chance for future stars to shine

Gary Ballance — the headline writer’s dream and the correspondent’s nightmare

An open letter to Pankaj Singh

India vs England 2014, 4th Test at Old Trafford: Should Umesh Yadav be sent as cover for Ishant Sharma?

5 things you need to know about Graham Thorpe

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

658 Posts | 6 Fans

Sachin Tendulkar's nine dismissals against James Anderson

Exclusive: I can never match up to Karan Johar says Niranjan Iyengar

Shah Rukh Khan: I want to continue working as long as I live

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here