Home > Features > Facts and figures >

Dale Steyn vs James Anderson: You’ve got it wrong, Alastair Cook

Dale Styen and James Anderson © Getty Images
Dale Steyn has a 32% better average than James Anderson, and a 40% better strike rate © Getty Images

Alastair Cook has come up with a rather curious comment, putting James Anderson and Dale Steyn in “the same class.” Abhishek Mukherjee explains why the comparison was a ludicrous one.

Though he is out-of-form off late, Alastair Cook is a fine batsman; a lot of critics had once vouched for him as the man who would go past Sachin Tendulkar’s records for most runs and hundreds. He was a struggling captain until recently, but he has found his groove back with back-to-back victories against India at Southampton and Old Trafford. Despite the criticism during the Ashes whitewash and the home series defeat against Sri Lanka, Cook is generally loved by all and sundry (including this columnist).

However, the same Alastair Cook has come out with a recent statement, comparing Dale Steyn and James Anderson: “You would put both of them in the same class.” While encouraging your spearhead is something expected of a captain, it is not a good idea to go overboard.

Let us compare the two men, who have been in the battle for the next man to the 400-wicket mark for some time now.

  M I W Ave SR 5WIs 10WMs W/I W/M
James Anderson

99

184

378

29.83

58.3

16

2

2.05

3.82

Dale Steyn

75

142

383

22.56

41.7

24

5

2.70

5.11

Ratio      

1.32

1.40

   

1.31

1.34

Let us have a look at the ratios: Steyn has a 32% better average than Anderson, and a 40% better strike rate. His wicket-per-match and wicket-per-innings are also over 30% when compared to Anderson’s. The comparison is really not a serious one. But, wait for a moment — did Cook want to say “in recent times” and had missed out on the phrase?

Year

Steyn

Anderson

Ave Ratio

SR Ratio

M W Ave SR M W Ave SR

2010

11

60

21.41

39.0

12

57

22.96

48.7

1.07

1.25

2011

5

28

19.57

38.2

7

35

24.85

50.8

1.27

1.33

2012

10

39

29.71

58.5

14

48

29.50

70.7

0.99

1.21

2013

9

51

17.67

42.0

14

52

31.82

61.3

1.80

1.46

2014

6

33

19.03

37.9

8

38

22.89

50.8

1.20

1.34

Since 2010

41

211

21.42

43.1

55

230

26.60

56.8

1.24

1.32

Steyn has a 24% better average and a 32% better strike rate. Let alone better, Anderson’s numbers are not even comparable to Steyn’s! What did Cook imply then? An opposition-wise break-up? Did he intend to mean that Anderson’s records are better than Steyn’s against certain opponents (barring Bangladesh and Zimbabwe)?

Opposition

Steyn

Anderson

Ave Ratio

SR Ratio

M W Ave SR M W Ave SR
Australia

14

69

27.13

45.8

23

77

36.96

67.0

1.36

1.46

England

11

46

32.63

56.3

India

12

63

20.93

40.4

19

80

27.41

55.1

1.31

1.36

New Zealand

10

58

17.05

34.3

10

46

25.04

43.5

1.47

1.27

Pakistan

10

47

21.82

44.3

7

32

17.65

46.5

0.81

1.05

South Africa

17

57

38.07

71.5

Sri Lanka

7

35

23.45

41.2

8

30

30.30

62.3

1.29

1.51

West Indies

6

35

18.68

34.3

11

36

27.72

59.9

1.48

1.75

Once again, the numbers are not comparable. Pakistan is the only country against whom Anderson has a better average, and even against them Steyn has a better strike rate. What, then, induced Cook to make the statement? Was it about venues (once again, we are leaving out Bangladesh and Zimbabwe, but including UAE)?

Opposition

Steyn

Anderson

Ave Ratio

SR Ratio

M W Ave SR M W Ave SR
Australia

6

30

28.03

48.1

13

43

38.44

69.3

1.37

1.44

England

5

23

31.65

55.4

58

248

26.53

53.3

0.84

0.96

India

5

26

20.23

34.5

7

22

29.81

62.9

1.47

1.82

New Zealand

3

9

26.55

66.8

5

18

36.27

58.6

1.37

0.88

Pakistan

2

9

24.66

37.0

South Africa

40

214

21.39

39.9

5

18

38.72

65.6

1.81

1.64

Sri Lanka

4

21

24.71

39.0

4

11

40.72

74.0

1.65

1.90

UAE

4

14

32.78

65.2

3

9

27.66

71.8

0.84

1.10

West Indies

3

15

18.13

33.0

4

9

38.00

86.0

2.10

2.61

Anderson is certainly a better bowler at home (and has a better average at UAE, though Steyn has a better strike rate; Anderson has a better strike rate in New Zealand as well, but Steyn is easily the better bowler across venues. Let us add three more parameters, then, to be sure.

Parameter

Steyn

Anderson

Ave Ratio

SR Ratio

M W Ave SR M W Ave SR
Matches won

40

269

15.89

31.3

44

207

22.63

44.9

1.42

1.43

Overseas (Away + Neutral)

35

169

24.05

43.9

41

130

36.13

67.9

1.50

1.55

In Asia

17

84

22.64

39.7

14

42

32.71

67.7

1.44

1.71

Surely there cannot be a comparison, Alastair Cook. But hang on, has Anderson been even the second best since 2010? Let us check (using a 100-wicket cut-off) and sort them by average:

  M I W Ave SR 5WIs 10WMs W/I W/M
Dale Steyn

41

79

211

21.42

43.1

13

2

2.67

5.15

Vernon Philander

26

51

115

21.57

45.8

9

2

2.25

4.42

Ryan Harris

24

46

103

22.56

48.3

5

0

2.24

4.29

Saeed Ajmal

30

56

157

26.45

61.7

10

4

2.80

5.23

James Anderson

55

104

230

26.60

56.8

9

2

2.21

4.18

If we use strike rates, on the other hand, Anderson is not even the top English bowler from the last five years.

  M I W Ave SR 5WIs 10WMs W/I W/M
Dale Steyn

41

79

211

21.42

43.1

13

2

2.67

5.15

Vernon Philander

26

51

115

21.57

45.8

9

2

2.25

4.42

Mitchell Johnson

29

55

127

26.74

47.5

8

2

2.31

4.38

Ryan Harris

24

46

103

22.56

48.3

5

0

2.24

4.29

Tim Southee

28

52

108

27.49

54.5

3

1

2.08

3.86

Morne Morkel

40

77

143

27.95

56.3

5

0

1.86

3.58

Stuart Broad

50

92

190

28.22

56.6

9

2

2.07

3.80

James Anderson

55

104

230

26.60

56.8

9

2

2.21

4.18

I’m sorry, Alastair Cook, but like many others, you have erred by comparing a once-in-a-generation bowler to a very good one. Steyn will be a contender for an all-time World XI by the time he retires; Anderson will struggle to make it to an all-time English XI.

(Abhishek Mukherjee is the Deputy Editor and Cricket Historian at CricketCountry. He blogs at http://ovshake.blogspot.in and can be followed on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/ovshake42)

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Nov 17, 2014 (11:30 IST)   at Dubai

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Nov 21, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Chittagong

Hong Kong tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Nov 22, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Dambulla

South Africa tour of Australia, 2014

Nov 23, 2014 (08:50 IST)   at Sydney

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Nov 23, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Chittagong

More

Hong Kong tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Nov 21, 2014  at Dambulla

Match abandoned without a ball being bowled

South Africa tour of Australia, 2014

Nov 21, 2014  at Melbourne

Australia won by 3 wkts

Hong Kong tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Nov 20, 2014  at Dambulla

Match abandoned without a ball being bowled(Match rescheduled to 21/11/2014)

Hong Kong tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Nov 19, 2014  at Dambulla

Match abandoned without a ball being bowled

South Africa tour of Australia, 2014

Nov 19, 2014  at Canberra

Australia won by 73 runs

Photos

Australia vs South Africa, 3rd ODI at Canberra

Videos

SL vs Eng: Buttler practices wicketkeeping in nets

Live Cricket Score Bangladesh vs Zimbabwe 1st ODI at Chittagong: Bangladesh end on 281

Live Cricket Score Pakistan vs New Zealand, 2nd Test at Dubai, Day 5: Pakistan 114/4 at Tea, still need 147 in last session

Live Cricket Score Vijay Hazare Trophy 2014-15 Quarter-Final 4, Punjab vs Railways: Punjab enter semi-finals with win

Live Cricket Score Vijay Hazare Trophy 2014-15 Quarter-Final 3 Mumbai vs Karnataka: Manish Pandey shines in Karnataka’s win

Live Cricket Score Australia vs South Africa 2014, 4th ODI Melbourne: Steven Smith’s century helps Australia register 3 wicket victory

Australia Australia vs South Africa Australia vs South Africa 2014 India New Zealand New Zealand tour of UAE 2014 New Zealand vs Pakistan New Zealand vs Pakistan 2014 Pakistan Pakistan vs New Zealand Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014 South Africa South Africa tour of Australia 2014 South Africa vs Australia South Africa vs Australia 2014

New Zeland need 6 wickets, Pakistan 147 behind target

Steven Smith’s ton powers Australia to 3-wicket win over South Africa in 4th ODI; seal series

Vijay Hazare Trophy 2014-15: Manish Pandey steers Karnataka into semi-final with 4-wicket win over Mumbai

Bangladesh vs Zimbabwe 2014, 1st ODI at Chittagong: Hosts set 282-run target courtesy Shakib Al Hasan, Mushfiqur Rahim stand

Vijay Hazare Trophy 2013-14: Yuvraj Singh’s half-century takes Punjab to 5 wicket win against Railways

Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014: Highest chases against New Zealand in Test matches

Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014: Pakistan’s biggest fourth innings chases

PCB’s biggest challenge is to bring back international cricket to Pakistan: Subhan Ahmad

Tim Southee’s 50 Test sixes and related records

India vs Australia 2014: India may have heavy dose of pace in store in 1st Test

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

681 Posts | 6 Fans

Video Highlights: Virat Kohli vs Australian cricketers

अमेरिका इबोला-रोधी मिशन का समय बढ़ा सकता है

Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014: Highest chases against New Zealand in Test matches

आईआईटी ने स्वच्छ भारत मिशन के तरफ अपना कदम बढ़ाया

Foxconn is investing $2.6 billion in a factory just for Apple: Bloomberg

Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014: Pakistan’s biggest fourth innings chases

Bigger Lenovo Vibe X2 variant’s purported photos and specifications leaked

Moderate intensity tremor jolts Kashmir

Roger Federer vs Gael Monfils Match 2 Live Streaming: Get Live Telecast of France vs Switzerland Davis Cup Final 2014

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here