Home > Features > Moments in history >

Hiralal Gaekwad: the southpaw who lost out to Vinoo Mankad

Hiralal Gaekwad © Getty Images
Hiralal Gaekwad © Getty Images

Hiralal Gaekwad, the Holkar mainstay, was born August 29, 1923. Abhishek Mukherjee looks at a left-arm bowler who missed out on an uneven contest with Vinoo Mankad for a slot in the national squad.

Hiralal Ghasulal Gaekwad was one of the few who went through the central state of India through its change of names: Central Provinces and Berar, Holkar, and Madhya Pradesh (he also played for Madhya Bharat once). Standing at 5’9”, Gaekwad was a versatile left-arm bowler. Don Moraes wrote of him in Green is the Grass: “Hiralal Gaekwad of Holkar can use the gloss as well as turn off the old ball’s seam.”

Gaekwad had a domestic career that spanned well over two decades. His numbers were impressive: his 374 wickets from 101 matches came at 23.62 apiece; he took 21 five-fors and five ten-fors. Also a handy batsman, Gaekwad scored 2,487 runs at 19.42 with two hundreds. In Ranji Trophy his numbers read an impressive 1,977 runs at 23.53 and 278 wickets at 22.07.

Unfortunately, his career coincided with a titan called Vinoo Mankad; with two other quality spinners (Subhash Gupte and Ghulam Ahmed) also being regular features in the side, breaking through to the side was almost impossible. As a result he ended up playing a solitary Test.

The Ranji Trophy master

Gaekwad was “brought” from Nagpur by CK Nayudu. He was also incorporated in Holkar Service. CK took him under his wings, and let him stay at Suraj Kothi, where CK himself stayed. As Chandra Nayudu later wrote in CK Nayudu: A Daughter Remembers, Gaekwad stayed there “till we left that house on father’s retirement from service.”

He made his First-Class debut against Madras at Nagpur, taking a solitary wicket. His first performance of note came in 1944-45, when he scored 73 batting at nine, adding 109 with Jamshed Bhaya for the eighth wicket against Bengal at Indore. Holkar lost to Bombay in that year’s Ranji Trophy final.

They made the upward journey next year as well, this time meeting Baroda in the final at home. Gaekwad had an excellent match: he took two for 21 and two catches in Baroda’s first innings to ensure a 144-run lead for the home side; then, with Holkar in trouble at 171 for nine against Baroda’s strong attack, Gaekwad, batting at ten, remained unbeaten on 79 and added 102 with OP Rawal for the last wicket.

Chasing 418 Baroda were on track with RB Nimbalkar and Hemu Adhikari taking the score to 109. Enter Gaekwad: he broke the partnership, and though Adhikari hung around, he accounted for him as well. He eventually finished with three for 76, and Baroda went down fighting, losing by 56 runs.

The first great bowling performance came the following season against Bengal at Indore: after Holkar put up 350, Gaekwad routed the tourists for 165 and 153 with figures of six for 42 and five for 32. Unfortunately, he was up against Vijay Hazare and Gul Mohammad in the final against Baroda at Baroda: the pair added a world record 577 for the fourth wicket; opening bowling, Gaekwad sent down 71 overs, finishing with three for 134; and Holkar were routed by an innings.

Holkar had another bite at the Ranji Trophy the next season, this time against Bombay at Indore. Once again Gaekwad rose to the occasion, helping rout Bombay with three for 19 and six for 90; he also scored 37, helping CS Nayudu put up 78 for the eighth wicket. Holkar lifted the Trophy again with a nine-wicket victory. With 29 wickets at 15.93, Gaekwad was named an Indian Cricket Cricketer of the Year.

Holkar kept on making it big in Ranji Trophy, with excellent performances from Gaekwad in almost every season. In 1948-49 he scored his first hundred, against Bihar at Jamshedpur: the hosts reduced Holkar to 160 for eight after they were bowled out for 188, but Gaekwad scored 109, adding 157 with K Bhatnagar for the ninth wicket; nicely warmed up by his effort, he went on to bowl out Bihar for 128 with figures of three for 27; he also took five catches in the match.

He fought a lone battle in the final at Indore that followed. He top-scored with 27 as Ranga Sohoni and Hazare bowled out Holkar for 188, following which Adhikari and Hazare almost batted them Holkar of the match with a third-wicket stand of 180. But Gaekwad simply refused to give up; he toiled hard as the last six Baroda wickets fell for 43; he finished with figures of 69-41-67-7 — his best in First-Class cricket. Despite his effort Holkar were defeated by nine wickets.

A strong Commonwealth XI toured India the following season. They played Holkar at Indore, and won by one wicket. Once again it was a one-man show: Holkar were bowled out for 86, but Gaekwad, bowling unchanged through the Commonwealth XI innings, kept Holkar in the match, restricting them for 197 with figures of five for 81. Set 190 for a victory, the tourists struggled against Gaekwad again: this time he finished with six for 71: the batting line-up, consisting of Frank Worrell, John Holt, and Wally Langdon, was certainly no pushover.

He was selected for an all-India XI to play against the tourists at Kanpur; he struggled with the ball, but still managed to return match figures of four for 191 as Worrell, batting at his best, played unbeaten knocks of 223 and 83. His form continued as he returned figures of four for 84 and two for 49 against the same opposition at Nagpur.

His next five innings read four for 36 and six for 84 (against Bengal at Indore), five for 91 and five for 102 (against Bihar at Indore), and four for 98  in addition to an 89 (against Delhi at Kotla in the semifinal). The revenge against Baroda at Baroda in the final was executed: batting at ten Gaekwad scored 59 out of a 96-run stand with Pratap Singh, removed Gul Mohammad and the unrelated Datta Gaekwad, and Holkar won comfortably.

A different Commonwealth XI (which included Worrell again, and was captained by Les Ames, no less) toured India the following season, and once again Gaekwad picked up five for 75 against them. He followed it with five for 27 against Uttar Pradesh at Dehra Dun next match.

Later that season he scored 164 (out of a team score of 203 during his stay) — his highest First-Class score — and finished with a match haul of five for 49 against Bihar at Jamshedpur. He finished with 295 runs at 36.84 and 23 wickets at 29.39. They could not keep him out any longer: he was selected for the England tour of 1952.

Test cricket

Despite India’s shambolic display, Gaekwad did not get to play a single Test on the tour. In fact, he played only ten matches on the tour, and was under-bowled (he got less than 20 overs a match). Despite that he finished the tour with 17 wickets at 27.29. He returned figures of five for 43 against Essex at Ilford (a match the hosts saved with nine wickets down); in his next match he had four for 32 against Glamorgan at Cardiff, but never got a decent spell after that. He also played against a Commonwealth XI (this time in England), had 51 not out and figures of four for 34 to show, but was still overlooked.

To be fair to the selectors, the series saw Mankad at his prime. The trend continued against the Pakistanis at home, where Mankad single-handedly routed them at Kotla with figures of eight for 52 and five for 79. Unfortunately, Mankad could not play the next Test at Lucknow, and Gaekwad made his debut (as did Shah Nyalchand).

Unfortunately, the Test was played on a coir-matting wicket; in Fazal Mahmood Pakistan had perhaps the greatest ever exponent of matting wickets; Fazal ran through India with five for 52 and seven for 42 as the hosts were bowled out for 106 and 182. Gaekwad scored 14 and eight, and was bowled by Fazal in each innings.

Between the two innings, Nazar Mohammad scored the first hundred for Pakistan, carrying his bat through the Pakistan innings with a 515-minute 124. Gaekwad toiled hard against Nazar, but went wicket-less, and conceded 47 off his 37 overs. Mankad replaced him in the third Test at Brabourne Stadium, and claimed eight for 124 in the Test and scored 41 and 35 not out; India won the Test by ten wickets, and Gaekwad never played another Test.

The Eden Gardens epic

That season’s Ranji Trophy final at Eden Gardens would certainly go down as one of the epic contests in the history of the tournament. Gaekwad bowled a marathon spell again (74.4-30-128-4) as Bengal amassed 479; BB Nimbalkar’s 219 (and a last wicket partnership worth 40 with Sayajirao Dhanawade) gave Holkar a 17-run lead, almost sealing the match for Holkar.

But Bengal struck back: Surjuram Girdhari and Benu Das Gupta added an unbroken 126 for the sixth wicket, and Probir Sen declared the innings closed at 320 for five (scored from 48 overs) on the fifth morning. Set 304 for a win, Holkar found themselves in tatters at 21 for three.

The fourth wicket stand saw 70 runs being added, but the Bengal bowlers kept striking: they needed to bowl out Holkar to force a victory; a draw, on the other hand, would result in a Holkar victory on first innings lead. Gaekwad walked out to bat at 132 for seven, and saw Holkar being reduced to 149 for nine as Dhanawade walked out to bat with 70 minutes to play.

The next hour-and-ten-minutes would surely rank among the most tense in a Ranji Trophy final. A ball even hit Dhanawade’s pad and rolled on to the stumps, but the bails were not dislodged. Eventually Gaekwad, unbeaten on 17, saw Holkar save the match. It remained Holkar’s final Ranji Trophy title.

Later years

Gaekwad was never reconsidered for the international level, but he continued to serve Holkar, who became runners-up in the next two editions of Ranji Trophy (Gaekwad picked up four wickets in each match). He continued to play for Madhya Pradesh after the name changed.

At Nagpur against Vidarbha in 1957-58, Gaekwad picked up three for 77 and seven for 68; in the second innings he went on to become the first Madhya Pradesh bowler to take seven wickets in an innings. They remained the best figures for a Madhya Pradesh bowler till Manzur Hasan took seven for 54 a decade later.

Against Rajasthan at Jabalpur at the age of 39, Gaekwad clean bowled Ramesh Shah, Gundibail Sunderam, and Subhash Gupte in consecutive deliveries. It remains the only hat-trick by a Madhya Pradesh bowler (though Chandu Sarwate had taken a hat-trick for Holkar earlier).

Gaekwad’s First-Class appearances became sporadic, but he played till 1963-64. In his last match, against Vidarbha at Nagpur, he scored 42 and four, and returned match figures of four for 58 from 53 overs. He ended the season on a high, finishing with 13 wickets at 15.07.


A matriculate by qualification, Gaekwad became a school inspector after his tenure at Holkar Service. He passed away at 79 on January 2, 2003 at Bagdogra. The Madhya Pradesh Under-18 tournament is named after him.

(Abhishek Mukherjee is the Deputy Editor and Cricket Historian at CricketCountry. He blogs here and can be followed on Twitter here.)

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (14:00 IST)   at Port Elizabeth

Sri Lanka tour of New Zealand, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (03:30 IST)   at Christchurch

India tour of Australia, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (05:00 IST)   at Melbourne

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Jan 2, 2015 (14:00 IST)   at Cape Town

Sri Lanka tour of New Zealand, 2014-15

Jan 3, 2015 (03:30 IST)   at Wellington


Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 19, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

New Zealand won by 68 runs

India tour of Australia, 2014-15

Dec 17, 2014  at Woolloongabba, Brisbane

Australia won by 4 wkts

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 17, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

New Zealand won by 7 runs

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Dec 17, 2014  at Centurion

South Africa won by an innings and 220 runs

England tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Dec 16, 2014  at Colombo

Sri Lanka won by 87 runs


India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane


Ind vs Aus: Dhoni analyses the 4-wicket loss at Brisbane

Murali Vijay’s 144 among most runs scored by an Indian on Day 1 of overseas Test

Live Cricket Score Ranji Trophy 2014-15, Round 3, Day 1 — All matches

India’s collapse against Australia on 2nd Test at Brisbane: Did the visitors really bat badly on Day 4?

India vs Australia 2014-15, Brisbane: India marks out of 10

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane: India’s tail tales

Anil Kumble Australia India Moments in history Ricky Ponting South Africa

Murali Vijay enters Top 20 ICC Test batsman rankings for first time

South Africa vs West Indies 2014-15: Rilee Rossouw replaces Quinton de Kock in Test squad

Ranji Trophy 2014-15 Round 3, Gujarat vs Saurashtra: Akshar Patel helps Gujarat reduce Saurashtra to 207

Ranji Trophy 2014-15 Round 3, Tamil Nadu vs Madhya Pradesh: Jalaj Saxena ton guides visitors to 250/4

Ranji Trophy 2014-15, Round 3, Goa vs Himachal Pradesh: Darshan Misal propels Goa to 274

Can Eoin Morgan change England’s limited-overs fortunes?

Pakistan vs New Zealand ODI series 2014: A look back at the series

Murali Vijay’s 144 among most runs scored by an Indian on Day 1 of overseas Test

Virat Kohli, Steve Smith and others scoring century on their Captaincy Debut in Test cricket

Batsman given hit wicket after mobile phone falls on stumps

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

683 Posts | 6 Fans

Mitchell Johnson's 37 wickets against England in Ashes 2013-14

प्रसिद्ध कथक नृत्यांगना सितारा देवी नहीं रही

More broadband connections to boost GDP growth in Asia Pacific: GSMA

India is becoming our largest overseas market, Xiaomi CEO Lei Jun says

Bigg Boss 8: Ali Quli Mirza, Renee Dhyani, Upen Patel, Praneet Bhatt, Sonali Raut – who should be evicted this week?

Revealed: The reason why Kishore Kumar’s biopic starring Ranbir Kapoor won’t feature Katrina Kaif!

अभिनेत्री प्रियंका चोपड़ा ने स्वच्छ भारत अभियान में हिस्सा लिया

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here