Home > Features >

India tour of New Zealand 2014: MS Dhoni should be relieved from Test captaincy

MS Dhoni © Getty Images
MS Dhoni should be worried about his poor record overseas © Getty Images

By Manish Madhusoodan

 

Preamble

Back in 2008 after the infamous Monkeygate scandal during the tour of Australia, it was logical to hand the captaincy over to the man who had done well in the limited overs, Mahendra Singh Dhoni. He had proven track record of winning the inaugural ICC World Twenty20 2007 and the future of Indian cricket seemed to in safe hands. It has been 53 Tests, six years since that moment elapsed, India has gone on to the top, slipped down the ridges, stooped to the lowest possible point, dug deeper holes, shot more bullets into the foot and still finds a new Nadir each time.

Philosophy

Imagine a sailor with the best possible equipment, state of the art design and the best men in the business, takes his mighty vessels with loads of expectation on his shoulder every single time, to each country he takes his ship — to the West Indies, England, Australia, South Africa and New Zealand. He returns empty handed, and each time with new excuses. Wonder if the sailor would have held his job? Talking in context of Dhoni, it is true that the first part of the trip he had a old and out of form  players, but in the latter half of the stint he had what he wanted, young, agile charismatic men. If these losses are unacceptable in any walk of life and why should it be allowed in the game of cricket? If we praised and lauded the captain for the success, we need to do the exact opposite when the results don’t come by. Giving positive points for the captain for the success and the not giving negative points when he fails is unfair on the captain too!

Numbers

Five countries, four continents 12 winless Tests abroad is a lot of baggage any captain carry and yet remain the head of the ship. Dhoni’s Test record of 26 victories, 14 defeats and 13 draws in 53 games stands 10th in the all time list of captains, and the best for an Indian captain. Eleven of those 14 losses have come away and 10 in the last leg; thereby making him the Indian captain with worst away Test loss record.

If I were Dhoni, then I would be worried about the negative record more, even though my positive record is one to be proud of. Incidentally Dhoni is also the captain with best and worst win and loss record among all the Indian captains. If we still think Dhoni should remain the captain then there is either something fundamentally wrong.

The last time India won a Test abroad was in June 2011 in the West Indies. It was just before Google bought Motorola Mobility; since then Moto has replaced its CEO and when nothing turned into profit it finally sold the company to Lenovo. Though captaining a team isn’t akin running a business, but one can draw parallels from it.

In the last couple of months we have seen India hand over the platter to the opposition, first in Johannesburg, and now in Wellington. It’s not just about the results; it’s also about the misplaced field positions and bizarre team selection which needs to be questioned. When New Zealand were 200 odd behind, Ravindra Jadeja was bowling over the wicket to Brendon McCullum. Even though he was an attacking batsman, by bowling a negative line you are not giving your bowler an opportunity to pick a wicket. The onus was on India to pick wickets, New Zealand just had to bat time and runs would come and they came.

Dhoni is famous for his ‘leather-chasing’ field placement, as one could advise his bowler to bowl tighter line and length. There wasn’t any deep square leg and yet the bowler would bowl a short ball into the body that would easily get dispatched to boundary, and the captain would go through the motions. Dhoni certainly didn’t look the captain was in charge of the situation.

When India were batting in the seconded innings, we saw two mid-wickets and short extra-cover being place to Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, thereby setting up a trap for the flick that goes in the air.

 

Being a good ODI captain need not necessarily translate into a good Test captain

It’s not a new for teams to have different captains for different formats. The game’s formats are as different as calk and cheese. You need different approaches, different skills and it won’t be wrong if you choose different men to lead them. India wouldn’t be the first country doing so.

Dhoni is a good limited-overs captain, but his captaincy doesn’t impress much in Test cricket, especially while playing abroad.  He doesn’t bring that same enthusiasm in Tests; either he is too defensive at times or just goes through the motions. The latter is a sign of a fatigued captain. It’s the right time to hand over the captaincy to Kohli, who has shown some maturity at least in his batting and the way he responsibly construct his innings. If not anything better, we can see some fresh ideas, and hopefully some interesting changes.

Also India have less than year before they begin their quest to retain the all important World Cup in 2015, and hence relieving Dhoni’s captaincy from Tests, might help India’s cause. Dhoni is 32-years-old, though he is fit as a fiddle he might be tired mentally. He is valuable to the India team, as a wicketkeeper and One-Day International (ODI) batsman and captain, he need to be preserved and taken care of. Who knows the Test captaincy sacking could be blessing in disguise, that one day Mahendra Singh Dhoni would realise.

(Manish Madhusoodan is a US-based software engineer who is a devotee of Test cricket. He blogs at desigiri.net)

Pakistan vs Australia in UAE, 2014

Oct 30, 2014 (11:30 IST)   at Abu Dhabi

Sri Lanka tour of India, 2014

Nov 2, 2014 (14:30 IST)   at Cuttack

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Nov 3, 2014 (09:00 IST)   at Khulna

South Africa tour of Australia, 2014

Nov 5, 2014 (14:05 IST)   at Adelaide

Sri Lanka tour of India, 2014

Nov 6, 2014 (14:30 IST)   at Ahmedabad

More

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Nov 15, 2014  at Ahmedabad

Match cancelled

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Nov 7, 2014  at Bengaluru

Match cancelled

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 30, 2014  at Hyderabad

Match cancelled

South Africa tour of New Zealand, 2014

Oct 27, 2014  at Hamilton

No result

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Oct 25, 2014  at Dhaka

Bangladesh won by 3 wkts

Photos

Pakistan vs Australia, 2nd Test: Australia's practice session

Videos

Tendulkar provides teaser on upcoming book

Rohit Sharma gave a fantastic account of himself: Sanjay Bangar

Yuvraj Singh flays media for twisting statements on future in international cricket

India A beat Sri Lanka by 88 runs in tour match; Rohit Sharma, Manish Pandey, Karn Sharma shine

Kevin Pietersen saga: Stuart Broad, James Anderson saddened by bullying claims

India vs Sri Lanka 2014: Rohit Sharma or Ajinkya Rahane — who should open for India?

Australia Australia tour of UAE 2014 Australia vs Pakistan Australia vs Pakistan 2014 Central Zone Duleep Trophy Duleep Trophy 2014-15 India Pakistan Pakistan vs Australia Pakistan vs Australia 2014 South Zone South Zone vs Central Zone Sri Lanka Sri Lanka tour of India 2014

West Indies crisis: Trinidad and Tobago condemns West Indies’ pullout from India tour

MS Dhoni told me there’s nothing called ‘lucky’ or ‘unlucky’: Pankaj Singh

All-India PSU T20 Tournament: Oriental Insurance defeat HPCL

Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif in favour of Najam Sethi as ICC President

Justice Mudgal Committee report on IPL spot-fixing to be submitted on November 3

Younis Khan’s ban: why the ICC is justified

KL Rahul could be opening option for India’s tour to Australia

Highest identical scores in both innings of a Test

Younis Khan — perhaps Pakistan’s greatest batsman ever

India A vs Sri Lankans tour match: Players look to make the most of opportunities

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

678 Posts | 6 Fans

Video Highlights: Younis Khan century during Pakistan vs Australia 1st Test at Dubai

India A vs Sri Lanka: Fringe players look to impress

NGOs pursue education for all

Dance Basanti from Ungli: Put on your dancing shoes and practice the Basanti move!

Weight Loss Tip #59: Eat oranges to lose weight

Sensex surges 150 points in early trade to regain 27,000-mark

PricewaterhouseCoopers partners Google to offer business solutions to clients

Google X Lab working on nanoparticles to help detect diseases early

Priyanka Chopra has the best no make-up selfie on Instagram, think fans!

Lisa Haydon: I slept off midway while watching the original Shaukeen!

International programme in Animal Husbandry

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here