Home > Features >

India vs England 1st Test at Trent Bridge: Did MS Dhoni miss a trick by not declaring?

    MS Dhoni-led India had a chance to declare and put England under pressure © Getty Images
MS Dhoni-led India had a chance to declare and put England under pressure © Getty Images

India drew their opening Test match of their five-match series against England at Trent Bridge after batting for the entire day as Stuart Binny and Bhuvneshwar Kumar completed half-centuries. Shiamak Unwalla wonders whether the match could have panned out differently had MS Dhoni declared earlier.

India started Day Five at a comfortable 167 for three, with Virat Kohli and Ajinkya Rahane at the crease. A lead of 128, with seven wickets remaining, at the start of the fifth day of a Test in England is usually a safe place to be.

However, being 184 for six — leading by only 145— with just four wickets remaining and not a single genuine top-order batsman left, is a rather insecure position to be in. Yet, that is where India found itself merely an hour into the day’s play.

It was left to Ravindra Jadeja, who has a highest Test score of 43, debutant Stuart Binny, and first innings hero, Bhuvneshwar Kumar to rescue India. And rescue India they did, in a rather convincing fashion. Binny combined first with Jadeja, and then Bhuvneshwar to take India out of danger and put them firmly in the driver’s seat.

Jadeja was dismissed for 31, with the score on 249. India had a lead of 210 at that point, with around 50 overs remaining in the day’s play. Had Dhoni declared then, the match would have been wide open.

It would have shaken England out of their stupor immediately, and could have left them jaded in their chase. With Alastair Cook in poor form, and the English mindset being decidedly defensive, the risk of them chasing down those runs was almost negligible. In fact, Cheteshwar Pujara had said on Day Four that the pitch was quite difficult to score quickly on.

Keeping this in mind, had Dhoni declared, the ball would have been firmly in England’s court. Without a batsman of the calibre of Kevin Pietersen  to help felicitate the chase, England could well have been caught in two minds whether to go for glory or be content with a draw.

A few wickets in this scenario could have led to panic in the ranks of a largely inexperienced batting line-up — Sam Robson, Gary Ballance and Moeen Ali have played a grand total of 10 Tests between them — which could have been exploited by the Indian bowlers.

Of course, this is all mere conjecture. It is equally possible that England would have batted out the remaining overs placidly, and both teams would have called off play an hour early, and enjoyed with a beer at the famous Trent Bridge inn.

However, the fact that both Dhoni and England skipper Cook were content on drawing — Cook brought himself and Gary Ballance on to bowl at one point — does not bode particularly well for the series. Perhaps with a bit more positive intent, Dhoni could have sent a very strong message to an opposing captain who has precious little confidence at the moment (but who admittedly had enough confidence in his bowling to send down two overs of his wibbly wobbly  part-timey stuff.

India held out to a draw, thereby managing not to lose the first Test of a series in England for only the fourth time since 1932. In that respect, it could be considered a victory for the visitors. However, if India are to have any chance of actually winning this series, Dhoni will need to be more aggressive and take a few more risks.

Complete coverage of India’s tour of England 2014

(Shiamak Unwalla is a reporter with Cricket Country. He is a self-confessed Sci-Fi geek and Cricket fanatic who likes to pass his free time by reading books, watching TV shows, and eating food. Sometimes all at the same time. You can follow him on twitter at @ShiamakUnwalla)

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Dec 17, 2014 (14:00 IST)   at Centurion

India tour of Australia, 2014-15

Dec 17, 2014 (05:29 IST)   at Woolloongabba, Brisbane

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (14:00 IST)   at Port Elizabeth

Sri Lanka tour of New Zealand, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (03:30 IST)   at Christchurch

India tour of Australia, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (05:00 IST)   at Melbourne

More

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 19, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

New Zealand won by 68 runs

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 17, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

New Zealand won by 7 runs

England tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Dec 16, 2014  at Colombo

Sri Lanka won by 87 runs

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 14, 2014  at Sharjah

Pakistan won by 147 runs

England tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Dec 13, 2014  at Pallekele

Sri Lanka won by 90 runs

Photos

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane

Videos

Josh Hazlewood looks back at his 5-wicket haul

Live Cricket Score India vs Australia 2014-15, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Australia win by 4 wickets

Pakistan vs New Zealand, 5th ODI at Abu Dhabi: Key clashes

Live Cricket Score, South Africa vs West Indies,1st Test, Day 3 at Centurion: Samuels and Chanderpaul rebuild for West Indies

Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014, 5th ODI at Abu Dhabi Preview: Teams prepare for high-octane finale

Anil Kumble Australia India Moments in history Ravichandran Ashwin Ricky Ponting South Africa

Australia beat India by 4 wickets in 2nd Test at Brisbane; take unassailable 2-0 series lead

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Steven Smith run out with 8 needed to win

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Shaun Marsh out for 17

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Ishant Sharma takes third wicket

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Chris Rogers scores crucial half-century

New Zealand vs Pakistan, 5th ODI at Abu Dhabi: Marks out of 10 for Kiwis

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane: India’s tail tales

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane: India’s tail ought to take leaf out of Australian tail’s book

India vs Australia 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 3: India’s pathetic bowling performance, Mitchell Johnson’s onslaught and other highlights

India’s inability to dismiss Australia’s tail can have huge impact

Fan of the Day

Suraj Gowda

Suraj Gowda

653 Posts | 10 Fans

India vs Australia: Murali Vijay's 144, Video highlights

प्रसिद्ध कथक नृत्यांगना सितारा देवी नहीं रही

More broadband connections to boost GDP growth in Asia Pacific: GSMA

India is becoming our largest overseas market, Xiaomi CEO Lei Jun says

Bigg Boss 8: Ali Quli Mirza, Renee Dhyani, Upen Patel, Praneet Bhatt, Sonali Raut – who should be evicted this week?

Revealed: The reason why Kishore Kumar’s biopic starring Ranbir Kapoor won’t feature Katrina Kaif!

अभिनेत्री प्रियंका चोपड़ा ने स्वच्छ भारत अभियान में हिस्सा लिया

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here