Home > Features > Facts and figures >

Is strike rate more significant than average to prove bowler’s success?

Mitchell Johnson © Getty Images
These are the strike bowlers the captains crave for: men who pick up wickets. To win matches a captain needs 20 wickets, and without strike bowlers, however containing a line-up you have, you will never win Tests © Getty Images

Over the years the bowling average has been a measure of how dangerous a bowler has been. Abhishek Mukherjee questions whether the oft-forgotten strike rate is a more appropriate measure.

Whenever there is a discussion regarding the choice of the most crucial parameter to measure a bowler’s achievements, the bowling average invariably comes up. Indeed, the bowling average has gone up with time; George Lohmann’s tally of 112 Test wickets at 10.75 will, it can be said safely, not emulated under the current playing conditions.

Let us, then, try to gauge the impact of time over bowling average.

Bowling-Averages-1

Of course, the period before World War II may provide misleading data due to the lesser number of Tests in the period. There are ways to calculate the gradient, fit a curve, and predict where things would reach in 2025, but one may assume that we have enough indication from the graph above.

Let us now go back to the formula of bowling average. It is basically a ratio of runs and wickets, which is one of the simpler definitions in the sport.

When we compare bowlers across era, we almost always take into account the fact that since bowling averages have increased over time, it will not be fair to compare bowlers across eras. For example, Curtly Ambrose’s average of 20.99 is usually considered a better number than Joel Garner’s 20.94 because of the eras they played in.

What we tend to forget, however, is the fact that the bowling average is a ratio. It has not been about the wicket-taking abilities of the bowlers: it has also been about the runs they have conceded over time.

Bowling-Averages-2

As is evident, the batsmen have been scoring at a faster rate, and are fast approaching the 3.50 runs-an-over mark, which is definitely an indicator of the increase bowling average: given that both parameters are dependent on runs, let us remove the find their ratio — to eliminate the concept of runs altogether.

So,

Bowling average / Economy rate

= (Runs / wicket) / (6 x Runs / ball)

= (1/6) * Balls / wicket

If we remove the constant value of 1/6 we are left with balls per wicket — which is nothing but the strike rate. Has the strike rate changed over time at all?

Bowling-Averages-3

Once the dull days of the 1960s were over, wickets kept falling as before (do note the low around the 1980-mark: guess which team was responsible for that?), and there is not much to choose between the 1940s and the 2010s in terms of bowling strike rate. This means that the bowlers have been taking wickets at least as frequently as they used to do, but they have been conceding more runs in the process.

These are the strike bowlers the captains crave for: men who pick up wickets. To win matches a captain needs 20 wickets, and without strike bowlers, however containing a line-up you have, you will never win Tests — which is why men like Chris Cairns got lost amidst a team of mediocre bowlers.

What, then, if we rank the bowlers according to their strike rates? Who are the top bowlers of the Post World War II era? Do we have the usual suspects there as well? Let us put a 200-wicket cut-off and check:

Top bowlers since World War II (cut-off: 200 wickets)

Player M W Bowling average Economy rate Strike rate
Dale Steyn 71 356 22.9 3.26 42
Waqar Younis 87 373 23.56 3.25 43.4
Malcolm Marshall 81 376 20.94 2.68 46.7
Allan Donald 72 330 22.25 2.83 47
Fred Trueman 67 307 21.57 2.61 49.4
Mitchell Johnson 58 255 27.56 3.3 50
Joel Garner 58 259 20.97 2.47 50.8
Richard Hadlee 86 431 22.29 2.63 50.8
Michael Holding 60 249 23.68 2.79 50.9
Darren Gough 58 229 28.39 3.3 51.6
Glenn McGrath 124 563 21.64 2.49 51.9
Dennis Lillee 70 355 23.92 2.75 52
Jeff Thomson 51 200 28 3.18 52.6
Brett Lee 76 310 30.81 3.46 53.3
Bob Willis 90 325 25.2 2.83 53.4
Makhaya Ntini 101 390 28.82 3.23 53.4
Chris Cairns 62 218 29.4 3.28 53.6
Imran Khan 88 362 22.81 2.54 53.7
Stuart MacGill 44 208 29.02 3.22 54

(Upto end of Day One, second Test between Australia and South Africa)

Ever wondered why Mitchell Johnson is considered so lethal? Why were batsmen at least as scared of Waqar Younis as they were of Wasim Akram? Why old-timers say that they have seldom seen anyone as deadly as Imran Khan at his pomp? Or those fans at SCG who claim that SCG MacGill had a raw deal? Despite their disparity in averages, why was Jeff Thomson as dangerous an option as Dennis Lillee?

The most surprising entries are possibly those of Darren Gough and Cairns: neither have been members of formidable teams, which made their successes with the ball go relatively unnoticed. However, they have managed to pick up wickets at intervals more frequently than the giants of the sport.

It would be unfair to club the spinners with the “glamour boys”: the slow men send down more overs, tie the batsmen down, and strangle their way to success. Let us look at them separately, then:

Top spinners since World War II (cut-off: 200 wickets)

Player M W Bowling average Economy rate Strike rate
Stuart MacGill 44 208 29.02 3.22 54
Muttiah Muralitharan 133 800 22.72 2.47 55
Shane Warne 145 708 25.41 2.65 57.4
Graeme Swann 60 255 29.96 2.98 60.1
Rangana Herath 51 217 30.01 2.8 64.2
Bhagwat Chandrasekhar 58 242 29.74 2.7 65.9
Anil Kumble 132 619 29.65 2.69 65.9
Saqlain Mushtaq 49 208 29.83 2.64 67.6
Danish Kaneria 61 261 34.79 3.07 67.8
Harbhajan Singh 101 413 32.37 2.83 68.5
Abdul Qadir 67 236 32.8 2.71 72.5

(Upto end of Day One, second Test between Australia and South Africa)

As mentioned before, MacGill leads the list: the two giants come next, and at five is the relatively unheralded Rangana Herath. Bishan Bedi might have had a delightful action and a mesmerising flight and loop; he might even have believed in buying a wicket at the cost of runs; but in reality he has managed to take a wicket every 80.3 balls — at a rate significantly worse than those of Bhagwat Chandrasekhar, Anil Kumble, or even Harbhajan Singh.

Do note how high Danish Kaneria is placed as well, and the comparative averages of MacGill and Lance Gibbs. If the bowlers had been bowling 50-over spells MacGill would have picked up 5.6 wickets on an average, while Gibbs would have returned a haul of 3.4 wickets.

However, the main test of a strike bowler is in victories, and Dale Steyn emerges at the top again. There is a surprise at the second position, though.

Top bowlers in victories since World War II (cut-off: 100 wickets)

Player M W Bowling average Economy rate Strike rate
Dale Steyn 37 247 16.12 3.09 31.2
Shoaib Akhtar 20 104 17.36 3.11 33.4
Richard Hadlee 22 173 13.06 2.33 33.5
Waqar Younis 39 222 18.2 3.12 35
Allan Donald 33 187 16.79 2.83 35.5
Darren Gough 18 105 19.94 3.28 36.4
Malcolm Marshall 43 254 16.78 2.64 38.1
Andy Caddick 21 114 19.67 3.08 38.2
Imran Khan 26 155 14.5 2.27 38.3
Dennis Lillee 31 203 18.27 2.8 39
Michael Holding 31 152 18.36 2.74 40.1
Fred Trueman 34 177 17.3 2.54 40.8
Mitchell Johnson 31 161 21.13 3.04 41.6
Andy Roberts 21 110 19.26 2.73 42.2
Wasim Akram 41 211 18.48 2.61 42.3
Muttiah Muralitharan 54 438 16.18 2.27 42.7
Makhaya Ntini 50 233 22.21 3.11 42.7
Ian Botham 33 172 20.09 2.77 43.4

(Upto end of Day One, second Test between Australia and South Africa)

Shoaib Akhtar was not one of the greatest bowlers in history, but when in full flow there have been few spectacles in world cricket to match him steam in to bowl. His raw pace has also delivered wins for Pakistan.

Surprisingly, though Cairns is absent here, both Gough and Andy Caddick have made it to the top ten: with a wicket every six overs in victories, one can only imagine what they could have done had they received proper support.

Let us do the obligatory table for spinners as well:

Top spinners in victories since World War II (cut-off: 100 wickets)

Player M W Bowling average Economy rate Strike rate
Muttiah Muralitharan 54 438 16.18 2.27 42.7
Anil Kumble 43 288 18.75 2.52 44.4
Stuart MacGill 31 165 24.4 3.14 46.5
Graeme Swann 30 150 22.66 2.84 47.8
Jim Laker 19 101 13.65 1.7 48
Danish Kaneria 23 120 21.91 2.68 49
Shane Warne 92 510 22.47 2.63 51.2
Derek Underwood 27 123 15.18 1.75 51.9
Harbhajan Singh 42 221 22.76 2.56 53.3
Abdul Qadir 21 100 23.49 2.6 54.2
Richie Benaud 24 128 18.32 1.9 57.7
Daniel Vettori 33 127 21.92 2.2 59.6
Lance Gibbs 30 154 19.16 1.9 60.4

Where is Warne? He’s down there, seventh on the list, below MacGill, Graeme Swann, and Kaneria — while Gibbs, somewhat predictably, languishes at the bottom. In fact, Gibbs’ strike rate in wins is worse than MacGill’s career strike rate.

Which country is the favourite hunting ground for bowlers, then?

Once again, the average does not provide the true story. The following graph will demonstrate that the average varies little depending on the host country:

Bowling-Averages-4

All the numbers, as evident, are between 30 and 35; this means that there is little to choose. The strike rate, however, gives us the real picture:

Bowling-Averages-5

Now we’re talking: a lot of runs are scored in Bangladesh, but wickets fall very fast. India is, as expected, the most difficult place for bowlers, but thanks to Murali and Herath, wicket-taking has not been as difficult in Sri Lanka.

So, from the next time, while you should not ignore the bowling average, the usually overlooked strike rate is a feature almost as handy. Remember, a strike rate below 60 is at least as impressive as an average below 30.

(Abhishek Mukherjee is the Deputy Editor and Cricket Historian at CricketCountry. He blogs at http://ovshake.blogspot.in and can be followed on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/ovshake42)

South Africa tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Jul 24, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Colombo

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 24, 2014 (12:30 IST)   at Bulawayo

India tour of England 2014

Jul 27, 2014 (15:30 IST)   at Southampton

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 6, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Galle

India tour of England 2014

Aug 7, 2014 (15:30 IST)   at Manchester

More

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 22, 2014  at Bulawayo

Afghanistan won by 2 wkts

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 20, 2014  at Bulawayo

Zimbabwe won by 8 wkts

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 18, 2014  at Bulawayo

Zimbabwe won by 6 wkts

India tour of England 2014

Jul 17, 2014  at London

India won by 95 runs

South Africa tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Jul 16, 2014  at Galle

South Africa won by 153 runs

Photos

Gallery: India vs England 2nd Test at Lord's

Videos

Alastair Cook jokes about his bowling

India’s wins in England — from 1971 to 2014

Ravindra Jadeja knighted by her majesty Queen Elizabeth II

India’s win over England in 2nd Test at Lord’s: Twitter reactions

Ishant Sharma pummels England into submission as India clinch Lord’s Test by 95 runs

Ishant Sharma registers name at Lord’s honours board, takes 6 wickets in 2nd Test against England

Bhuvneshwar Kumar England England vs India England vs India 2014 India India tour of England 2014 India vs England India vs England 2014 Ishant Sharma MS Dhoni South Africa South Africa tour of Sri Lanka 2014 Sri Lanka Sri Lanka vs South Africa Sri Lanka vs South Africa 2014

Sachin Tendulkar: Century at Perth in 1992 against Australia changed my career

Ishant Sharma latest to feature in Amul’s ad after India’s win in 2nd Test against England

Hashim Amla lauds Imran Tahir ahead of Sri Lanka vs South Africa second Test at Colombo

India tour of England 2014: Sourav Ganguly backs Alastair Cook as the skipper

Ishant Sharma signs deal with Cornerstone Sport

India vs England 3rd Test at The Ageas bowl: A sneak peek into England squad

Mohammad Irfan hopes Pakistani players will play in IPL

Stuart Binny and the selection conundrum for India’s third Test against England at Southampton

Can America be the ‘Land of Opportunity’ for cricket?

Graham Gooch’s fabulous numbers in all forms of cricket

Fan of the Day

Fan Cricket

Fan Cricket

11 Posts | 2 Fans

Brazil vs Netherlands, 3rd place Fifa World Cup 2014 match Video Highlights

Ishant Sharma latest to feature in Amul’s ad after India’s win in 2nd Test against England

Diet Tip #23 – Switch to rice bran oil for better health

Taiwan plane crash: 51 killed as plane crashes during emergency landing

Apple OS X Yosemite beta will be available to the public from tomorrow

Alia Bhatt feels she is too young to work with Shah Rukh, Salman and Aamir!

Sachin Tendulkar: Century at Perth in 1992 against Australia changed my career

BJP calls Sania Mirza ‘daughter-in-law’ of Pakistan, criticises Telangana for honouring her

Research questions satellite data over Antarctic sea expansion

Moon Moon Sen and Arindam Seal will also be honoured at Mahanayak Uttam Kumar Samman!

TransAsia Airways makes emergency landing in Taiwan, more than 50 feared dead

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here