Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here

Home > Features >

Monty Panesar incidents: The blurring line in racial taunts and jokes

Monty Panesar was mocked at twice last week  © Getty Images
Monty Panesar was mocked at twice last week © Getty Images

 

The last week has witnessed two unfortunate incidents in which Cricket Australia (CA) has had to apologize for actions of their contracted staff.

 

First, Nixon, the on-ground announcer at Alice Springs, introduced England left arm spinner Monty Panesar in an Indian accent. Panesar is an England cricketer and a Sikh. The Indian accent was seen around the world as an indication of Nixon, and hence CA perhaps, mocking an English player using a casually racist archetype.

 

CA was immediately on the back foot. They sacked Nixon and issued an apology.“Cricket Australia deemed the conduct of the PA announcer as inappropriate and as such he will take no further part in the match.”

 

This was perhaps an attempt at an edgy race-based joke that went horribly wrong. Nixon obviously thought so. In response to a tweet that indicated he had been stood down, he tweeted: “Really? I love Monty P — cult hero. He should bat at No 3. My style didn’t fit theirs. That’s all.” It was all a simple issue of a style-misfit.

 

On 5th December, CA was forced to issue an apology once again — and once again, Panesar was involved. CA’s official Twitter account posted a picture of four bearded and turbaned men, all dressed up as Teletubbies along with the tweet: “Will the real Monty Panesar please stand up?” The implication here was, of course, that all Sikhs (or Asians, if you wish to extrapolate the essence of the tweet) look alike and perhaps we need to give them different coloured clothing to tell them apart. This was, at best, an example of casual racism and, at worst, a comment that was potentially insulting to Panesar and Sikh people.

 

The tweet was immediately removed after outrage from around the world. CA, instead, said “We certainly apologise for any offence caused with the tweet. It wasn’t our intention to offend and it has promptly been removed from Twitter. To reiterate, if the tweet was interpreted in a manner that offended Twitter followers, we certainly apologise for that. This has been addressed internally and CA acknowledges it was an error of judgement.” Of course this was an edgy tweet gone wrong and clearly, things went pear-shaped very quickly for the tweeter and for CA.

 

Casual racism happens all around us. It happens when someone uses a particular characteristic of a person or a group of people and highlights that in order to make a point that they think is funny. They may make the remark even without humour as their intent, of course. More often than not, the person making the comment may not even realize what they have uttered is inherently racist; they just go with the flow.

 

In the David Nixon case, he conflated Indian accents with the fact that Panesar is brown-skinned and of Indian descent. That Panesar was born in Luton and speaks with an English accent did not stand in the way of Nixon having a laugh at Panesar’s expense. Perhaps we shouldn’t be thin skinned, prickly and hypersensitive about it. Perhaps we should laugh along with Nixon. If it was a friend I knew really well – and I knew that that friend did not have a racist bone in his body – I probably would have laughed along. If the context and setting was a stand-up comedy night, I may have laughed along too. However, Nixon was a formal announcer at a cricket game.

 

Comedians say silly things all the time and some of what they say may be interpreted as racially offensive. But then Louis CK is hardly ever called out for his comments – and some of them may be seen as casual racism – because that’s what comedians do all the time. They make rape jokes or racist jokes in a very careful and mostly tasteful manner, and in so doing, the good comics often enable us to think about our stereotypes, assumptions (and sometimes) identities. Through their work, they challenge or reinforce assumptions, identities and culture. And that is where we have the problem. The CA tweeter isn’t a comic and their context is very different to that of Louis CK.

 

In both these incidents, CA quickly issued an apology. That is the honourable thing to do. However, in both these incidents CA also hurriedly convened a meeting and “internally addressed” the inappropriate behaviour quickly. Note that CA has had to construct such internal courts quite often in the recent past to deal with either errant staff or a wayward player, or misbehaving cameramen named Joe.

 

It must be clear by now to CA that its twitter handler(s) and ground announcers need to demonstrate greater responsibility in undertaking their duties. It is all fine to be seen as the organisation that develops a ‘Spirit of Cricket’ document which is signed by all the people contracted to the organisation. It is also all fine to want to be seen as the organisation that wants to be respected as rule makers of the game. However, this is exactly the problem with meting out internal justice in hurriedly constructed boardroom courts and then being continuously deluded that all of this constitutes a legitimate world-view of the game.

 

In this instance, it is quite likely the CA tweeter was merely continuing the verbal jouststhat the Australian players and media have been dishing out to the visitors from England. The tweeter, a CA representative no less, threw his bit in to the verbal jousts, picked on the newest player to play in the series and came up with a crude and edgy tweet. That tweeter must have thought he wasn’t crossing the “line in the sand” that Australian officials constantly talk about.

 

For many years now, Australian cricket has been living under the impression that the unwritten rules it plays the game by are acceptable to [and lauded by] the world at large. And this is exactly why we keep hearing the phrase “line in the sand” a lot in the context of cricketers and sledging.

 

There are lines in the sand. But whose line do we go by? Yours or mine? Who is to say that my line is not better? After all, “monkey” is a phrase used in India a lot as a term of endearment. My line includes monkey. My line does not include a mockery of my accent or my religious head scarf. Whose line do we use?

 

And if we used Anil Kumble‘s line, would it have been acceptable to Andrew Symonds, CA and Australia at large if Anil Kumble had said exactly what CA said on Thursday and dealt with an ‘error in judgment’ internally?

 

And that is the problem with lines in sand. We need to continually ask: whose line is it anyway?

 

(Mohan Krishnamoorthy is an unabashed fan of cricket. He tweets at @mohank and blogs at www.i3j3cricket.com and mohankaus.blogspot.com. The above article was first published in DNA)

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 25, 2014 (16:00 IST)   at Dubai

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 25, 2014 (20:00 IST)   at Dubai

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 26, 2014 (16:00 IST)   at Abu Dhabi

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 26, 2014 (20:00 IST)   at Abu Dhabi

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 27, 2014 (16:00 IST)   at Sharjah

More

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 24, 2014  at Sharjah

Kolkata Knight Riders won by 2 runs

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 23, 2014  at Dubai

Chennai Super Kings won by 7 runs

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 22, 2014  at Sharjah

Kings XI Punjab won by 72 runs

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 21, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

Chennai Super Kings won by 93 runs

Indian T20 League 2014

Apr 20, 2014  at Sharjah

Kings XI Punjab won by 7 wkts

Photos

CSK vs DD, IPL 2014 Match 8 at Abu Dhabi

Videos

IPL: Tanmay Mishra talks shows the contents of his kit

Sachin Tendulkar — One of the hardest terms to optimise for any SEO professional

Sachin Tendulkar changed the fortunes of cricket journalists in India

Sachin Tendulkar — the greatest batsman of India

Sachin Tendulkar: A timeless fairytale

Sachin Tendulkar: The child, the father, but sexy? Not quite

Chennai Super Kings Delhi Daredevils Glenn Maxwell India IPL IPL 7 IPL 2014 Kings XI Punjab Kolkata Knight Riders MS Dhoni Rajasthan Royals RCB vs KKR RCB vs KKR 2014 Royal Challengers Bangalore Sunrisers Hyderabad

Moin Khan hints at change of captain for Pakistan’s ODI side

Chris Lynn helps Kolkata Knight Riders escape with stunning 2-run win over Royal Challengers Bangalore in Match 11 of IPL 2014

PCB change Muhammad Akram’s role from bowling coach to national selector

RCB need 18 off the last 2 overs against KKR

RCB lose Virat Kohli bust stay in control against KKR

Sachin Tendulkar given out off a wrong replay on his birthday in IPL 2011

Happy birthday! A bouquet of CricketCountry’s best Sachin Tendulkar features

Sachin Tendulkar – The century of centuries in tweets

Sachin Tendulkar — One of the hardest terms to optimise for any SEO professional

Sachin Tendulkar changed the fortunes of cricket journalists in India

Fan of the Day

Suraj Gowda

Suraj Gowda

622 Posts | 7 Fans

Video Highlights: Virat Kohli's 77 during India vs Sri Lanka ICC World T20 2014 final at Dhaka

New Indian-South Africa `academic bridge` launched

Are Himesh Reshammiya and Yo Yo Honey Singh overconfident about The Xpose?

Are electronic cigarettes actually safe for you?

Russia starts border army drill after Ukraine attacks rebels

Xbox users are spending 5 hours a day on the console!

7 health benefits of eucalyptus oil

IPL 2014: Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB) vs Kolkata Knight Riders (KKR), Match 11 at Sharjah

Vic Gundotra, Google+ head leaves company

Also on cricketcountry.com