Home > Features >

MS Dhoni would have to step down as captain if India loses at Nagpur

MS Dhoni would have to step down as captain if India loses at Nagpur

It’s make or break time for MS Dhoni the captain © Getty Images

A loss in the Nagpur Test will raise the demands for removal of MS Dhoni as captain to deafening levels. But is there a successor? Arunabha Sengupta examines whether all the brickbats thrown at the Indian captain are justified.

With defeats chasing India across England and Australia, and the last stages of the pursuit leading into their own backyard, the demand is for sweeping changes.

The losses have hurt national pride – especially the tame surrenders on home territory, on the same turf they have formerly ruled with swagger, where they have remained undefeated since 2004.

And when the disappointed voices of millions echo across the length and breadth of the nation, when public outcry rings out loud and clear, perhaps the only known remedy in the world is age-old and time-tested – perfected by the French during their famed revolution. Heads should roll.

The emotional upheaval of the cricketing fraternity can be soothed only by rolling heads – big and important ones.If India loses at Nagpur, several serious apexes are sure to come down crashing, victims of the cruel axe.

Zaheer Khan has already been shown the door – a fact that did not quite register in a big way on the batting-obsessed Indian cricketing consciousness. But, there are several other heavyweights queued up near the selectorial guillotine. The biggest among them is the man almost everyone believes does not deserve a place in the team based on performance – captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni.

It is not only the casual critics; even ex-Test cricketers have joined in the chorus, voicing that Dhoni has done little to merit a regular place in the side.The likelihood is that another defeat will soon see the selectorial thought process buckling underthe enormous public pressure.

If not Dhoni, who?

However, what the several voices have not provided is an alternative. If not Dhoni, who?

Gautam Gambhir, one of the names suggested eloquently during the course of last year, has had less to show for his efforts with the bat than the Indian captain. If the assertion that Dhoni does not merit a place in the team is indeed found to be true after stripping it of the passionate frenzy of the moment, Gambhir as a specialist batsman should be scampering away from the eleven way before the captain hands over his crown and wanders into wilderness.

The other name is Virender Sehwag. Since the litany of losses started for India from the beginning of the English summer, Sehwag has scored at 0.13 runs more than Dhoni per innings. And if we take only this home season into consideration, in the five Tests, Sehwag has scored 381 runs at 42.33, while Dhoni has managed 275 at 39.28. Given that Sehwag is an opening batsman and Dhoni, according to most knowledgeable opinions, a glorified lower order biffer, if the captain does not merit a place because of his performance, Sehwag must be very near the sack himself.

This places us in a quandary. Is there a replacement?

And hang on … there is another thought which seems to emerge from the figures.

Numerous former cricketers – the latest in the list being Mohinder Amarnath – have stressed that Dhoni does not have the technique for Test match batting and his performances have done little to get him into the side. He is there by pulling his weight as a captain.

Let us look again, this time detaching ourselves from the perceptions and concentrating on the data.
The batting statistics of MS Dhoni look immensely respectable when compared to the established batsmen of the team. It is rare – nay, almost unique –in the history of Indian cricket for a wicket-keeper to achieve this.

His technique may give nightmares to the purist, but the criticism of his performance as a batsman is a
figment of agenda-driven imagination riding on the fury of the masses.

Indian batsmen since English tour

Batsman T Runs Ave 100s 50s
SR Tendulkar 16 951 32.79 0 7
V Sehwag 14 865 33.26 1 5
MS Dhoni 15 762 33.13 1 6
G Gambhir 15 750 27.77 0 5
V Kohli 10 712 41.88 2 5
CA Pujara 5 628 89.71 3 0

Indian batsmen in current season

Batsman T Runs Ave 100 50
CA Pujara 5 628 89.71 3 0
R Ashwin 5 283 56.60 0 2
V Kohli 5 297 42.42 1 2
V Sehwag 5 381 42.33 1 0
MS Dhoni 5 275 39.28 0 3
G Gambhir 5 272 34.00 0 2
SR Tendulkar 5 173 21.62 0 1

The question remains – even if MS Dhoni is sacrificed to appease the national sentiments, adding the crown as a bonus along with the rolling head, whois the successor?

Virat Kohli with an average of 35.81 in his 13 Tests seems too raw in the longest version of the game to be launched against the Australians. Sehwag and Gambhir have not been very secure of their positions themselves. Yet, a loss will raise the public demands for a change at the top to deafening levels.

It will be interesting to see how Sandeep Patil and his men handle the situation.

(Arunabha Sengupta is a cricket historian and Chief Cricket Writer at CricketCountry. He writes about the history and the romance of the game, punctuated often by opinions about modern day cricket, while his post-graduate degree in statistics peeps through in occasional analytical pieces. The author of three novels, he can be followed on Twitter at http://twitter.com/senantix)

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 20, 2014 (14:30 IST)   at Kolkata

Pakistan vs Australia in UAE, 2014

Oct 22, 2014 (11:30 IST)   at Dubai

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 22, 2014 (19:00 IST)   at Cuttack

South Africa tour of New Zealand, 2014

Oct 24, 2014 (03:00 IST)   at Mount Maunganui

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Oct 25, 2014 (09:00 IST)   at Dhaka

More

South Africa tour of New Zealand, 2014

Oct 21, 2014  at Mount Maunganui

South Africa won by 6 wkts

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 17, 2014  at Dharamsala

India won by 59 runs

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 14, 2014  at Visakhapatnam

Match cancelled

Pakistan vs Australia in UAE, 2014

Oct 12, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

Australia won by 1 run

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 11, 2014  at Delhi

India won by 48 runs

Photos

India vs West Indies 4th ODI at Dharamsala

Videos

AB de Villiers speaks ahead of New Zealand ODIs

South Africa vs New Zealand 2014: 5 memorable matches

Yasir Shah: The new spinning sensation for Pakistan

Virat Kohli takes wicket with the first (0th?) ball of his T20I career

Kevin Pietersen’s autobiography — a litany of complaints with a few redeeming patches

Banning West Indian players in IPL can affect the ‘Brand value’ of the event – Will BCCI take this gamble?

Australia Australia tour of UAE 2014 India India vs West Indies India vs West Indies 2014 New Zealand Pakistan Salaam Cricket South Africa West Indies West Indies cancel India tour 2014 West Indies tour of India 2014 West Indies vs India West Indies vs India 2014

Duleep Trophy 2014 Semifinal, East Zone vs South Zone: Laxmi Ratan Shukla feels Lahli pitch will suit East Zone pacers

Harbhajan Singh to miss Duleep semi-final against Central Zone,Gautam Gambhir to captain North Zone

Duleep Trophy semi-final: Upbeat East Zone take on South Zone

Pakistan vs Australia 1st Test in Dubai Preview: Motivated Pakistan look to hurt rusty Australia

Pakistan vs Australia 2014, 1st Test: Michael Clarke, Misbah-ul-Haq ready for spin challenge

Pakistan’s chances in ICC World Cup 2015 bleak: Mohammad Zahid

Quinton de Kock equals wicketkeeping record with six catches in South Africa vs New Zealand 1st ODI

MS Dhoni rested, Virat Kohli as captain, and other points of interest from squad for first 3 India vs Sri Lanka ODIs

India vs Sri Lanka 2014: MS Dhoni gets much-needed break ahead of Australia tour

Virat Kohli becomes fastest to 20 ODI hundreds

Fan of the Day

Gautam Singh

Gautam Singh

474 Posts | 5 Fans

Video Highlights Mohammed Yousuf drops catch after watching a girl in bikini

अभिनेत्री हुमा कुरैशी ओरिफ्लेम की ब्रांड एंबेसडर

Has Bigg Boss 8 made Karishma Tanna the most hated person?

Pranab Mukherjee returns home after visit to Norway, Finland

Revealed: First look of Amitabh Bachchan-Farhan Akhtar’s Do!

7 reasons why having sex during pregnancy is great for your health

Videocon Infinium Graphite with gesture control feature launched, priced at Rs 10,499

Rupee up 19 paise against dollar in early trade

Twitter introduces Audio Cards to listen to music directly from your timeline

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here