Home > Features >

MS Dhoni’s momentary outburst about IPL – what does it signify?

Perhaps for the first time, chinks and crevices appeared beneath MS Dhoni’s legendary equanimity; the ice cold demeanour thawed and a small but significant surge of anger seeped out on to the otherwise inscrutable surface © Getty Images

In the post-match conference, smarting under the third humiliating defeat in a row, for a rare moment Mahendra Singh Dhoni’s equanimity was lost and his reply was uttered with a modicum of bad taste. Arunabha Sengupta tries to find out the merit of the question and answer sequence, and what it tells us about Indian cricket.

“Ask the BCCI, don’t be jealous of IPL.”

This had been captain MS Dhoni’s retort when asked whether a stint in county cricket would not be more beneficial for the Indian team prior to such tours than the Indian Premier League (IPL).

It was perhaps the first time that chinks and crevices appeared beneath the skipper’s legendary equanimity, the ice cold demeanour thawed and a small but significant surge of anger seeped out on to the otherwise inscrutable surface.

Had it been that unreasonable a question? Enough to break down a façade of calm perfected over a decade? Let us look at the evidence.

At Nottingham, with India struggling to save the Test on the final day, Ravindra Jadeja charged out at James Anderson, hitting the pace bowler straight back over his head for four.

At Lord’s the top order struggled to come to terms with the pitch. Only an extraordinary innings by Ajinkya Rahane and a fascinating rear-guard knock by Bhuvneshwar Kumar saved the team the blushes. In the second innings, Jadeja repeated his audacious advances, and for once it came off. His innings perhaps played the vital role in clinching the match in India’s favour. Before that, however, Stuart Binny had holed out off Moeen Ali without scoring, trying to hit one out of the ground when occupation of the wicket was the demand of the hour. Thankfully it did not prove expensive.

At Southampton, the Indian bowlers looked jaded. The discipline that had thus far been the bedrock of their performance, now showed signs of wavering. Bhuvneshwar had lost his accuracy, his movement, also the spring in his step. The batsmen got set and fell to relatively harmless deliveries, through snicks and bad shot selection. No one, Rahane apart, looked like building an innings.

The match was still in balance when Rohit Sharma charged down the wicket and hit Moeen down the throat of mid-off – the most outrageous of strokes even as Rahane and he were in the midst of a partnership that looked likely to take India much closer to the England total. In the second innings, with the match to be saved, Murali Vijay was run out attempting a short single. One by one the batsmen followed, again only Rahane intent on making an impression beyond a cameo. Many fell to the innocuous and often non-existent spin of Moeen.

By Manchester, the side seemed to have come apart at the seams. Gone were the exemplary restraint and perseverance of Murali Vijay, the brilliance of Kumar with bat and ball, the class and composure of Rahane. The Indian batting surrendered, with only captain Dhoni, the man with perhaps the worst technique in these conditions, making more runs than the ten other batsmen put together. The Virat Kohli-Cheteshwar Pujara duo, who had  flattered to deceive so far, refused to even go to the extent of flattering. In the second innings there was just a session to see through before rains were supposed to come down – and did. And the Indian batters gifted their wickets, a fair proportion to Moeen, by the bushel. The game was over within three days.

At The Oval, it was an eerie rerun of the previous Test. Once again the Indian batsmen floundered, once again Dhoni made more than all the other batsmen put together. The bowling was just jaded. By the final innings, no one had the will to fight.  The  white flag of surrender fluttered behind each batsman as he walked in and out. For the second time in succession the match was over in three days, for the fourth consecutive occasion the first five wickets yielded less than 65.

The invisible hand of Indian cricket governance was conspicuous all through, faintly during the first two matches and getting increasingly prominent from Ageas Bowl. That self-regulating behaviour that tried hard to reconstruct five day affairs into a more limited time-frame.

As long as men like Vijay, Rahane and Kumar had the fortitude to resist the urges and temptations of the shorter games, India batted like a Test team. They lasted 161 and 123 overs at Trent Bridge, even managed to negotiate a green pitch of Lord’s to bat for 91.4 and 103.1 overs, survived 106.1 overs the first time they batted at Rose Bowl. And then, the lack of First-Class preparation took its toll. It took England 66.4 overs to dismiss them in the second innings at Southampton, 46.4 and 43 overs at Old Trafford and 61.1 and 29.2 at The Oval.

The evidence is palpable

The side is far more suited for shorter versions where liberties and impulses can be indulged in without the arduous task of sticking around. The quality players started off well only to be mentally fatigued at an unused to ordeal of five day games by the end of the third Test. The bits and pieces cricketers, the likes of Stuart Binny and Ravindra Jadeja, found their ways into the team,underlining a thought processtraced around shorter versions. I guess it is high time to get rid of the delusion that Binny could be a miracle working swing bowler in English conditions. In three Tests he bowled 32 overs giving away 140 runs without anything to show for in the wickets column. Yes, I know one edge went between Dhoni and Shikhar Dhawan, but those are not the figures of a bowler ready for Test cricket.

Additionally, few batsmen had any clue about batting in such conditions. One fifty from 30 combined innings by four top order batsmen – Gautam Gambhir, Dhawan, Pujara and Kohli – leave little doubt about it.

Besides, we know that the IPL had been the usual full blown spectacle just before the England tour, and the Indian cricketers had been immersed deep in the waves of the loud and colourful tamasha. It seems in hindsight that they emerged from the festivities still soaked and dripping from the instant concoction of cricket.

Under these circumstances, is it too unreasonable to wonder whether the experience of county cricket, played on the English soil, battling the vagaries of the northern latitudes, the heavy atmosphere and fickle weather, would have been better preparation for such a series? After all, the past is littered with giants of the game who polished and perfected their techniques and methods in the finishing school of county cricket.

And neither was the question asked amidst the chaos and confusion that often attends media queries back home.

It seems that the question pricked a sensitive spot and out erupted the previously unseen puss and phlegm.

What made MS Dhoni lose his legendary cool?

“Ask the BCCI.” A clear indication that certain things are beyond his control. It cannot be said for sure whether Dhoni hinted that he himself was not happy with the preparation. After seven years of captaincy, does he not have even the slightest influence tomake BCCI pause, ponder and perhaps change some of their ways? If he doesn’t then there is every reason to lose his cool. But, clearly, he is not ready to answer the question.

The second part of the response was more of a glaring faux pas. It not only underlined that IPL was a topic that had the power to make the Indian captain lose his cool,  it painted him in angry colours for perhaps the first time in his tenure. It was a response that was aggressive, with allegations of jealousy thrown back at the journalists.

It is difficult to justify such an answer, but let me make an attempt nevertheless.

Ever since its inception, IPL has been condemned by several loud voices in unison. At the same time, a majority of the voices have tended to reduce their decibel levels and trickle off into deafening silence when the bandwagon has stopped in front of them with the invitation to jump on it. More often than not soon they have been heard on the other side, cheering with each DLF maximum.The voices that have continued to rage are generally the neglected ones who have been denied the opportunity to splurge in this cricketing orgy. The green eye of envy can be seen staring at the circus from the distant mounds and hills, after having been overlooked while invitations for a ringside view were being sent out.

Many of the proclaimed evils of IPL are so to say, right on the money. It is of course true that a spinner paid unthinkable amounts for bowling 24 balls, with an implied bonus for the dots, will fast lose the eagerness for 30-over days to purchase their wickets. However, often the same is stated with undue stress on the unthinkable amounts rather than the ‘lost eagerness’. Jealousy is a very basic human trait, and a base one. When opportunities have opened up for cricketers to reap the harvest of being exceptional in their field, onlookers droning on in begrudging moans can be infuriating to the professional cricketer. After all, he is not breaking rules to make his money.

However, being the captain of the Indian side carries certain unstated stipulations. One cannot react with anger in the face of abject failure, especially when the question – however unpleasant – is a very pertinent one. There is a certain accountability associated with every cricketer wearing national colours, and that cannot be ignored when the tints of franchises are brought under the spotlight of scrutiny.

Perhaps it has often been asked with more than a dose of that same envy that we see every day in every walk of life. But that is to be understood, and perhaps swallowed like an unavoidable, if slightly bitter, pill with the smile of steadfastness. Dhoni, till now, had been exceptional in withstanding difficult questions with good humour, without falling prey to outbursts in even the most extenuating circumstances. For once his composure wavered.

That was the only moment in the press conference when his mask of imperturbability slipped off, but it was significant. It was perhaps more than just the frustrations associated with repeated failures of the team. It seemed more likely that fine lines had been trespassed and delicate areas had been stepped into.

It is alarming that while Test match results leave the skipper calm and controlled, the mention of IPL can provoke such a reaction.

Complete coverage of India’s tour of England 2014

(Arunabha Sengupta is a cricket historian and Chief Cricket Writer at CricketCountry. He writes about the history and the romance of the game, punctuated often by opinions about modern day cricket, while his post-graduate degree in statistics peeps through in occasional analytical pieces. The author of three novels, he can be followed on Twitter at http://twitter.com/senantix)

Pakistan vs Australia in UAE, 2014

Oct 30, 2014 (11:30 IST)   at Abu Dhabi

Sri Lanka tour of India, 2014

Nov 2, 2014 (13:30 IST)   at Cuttack

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Nov 3, 2014 (09:00 IST)   at Khulna

South Africa tour of Australia, 2014

Nov 5, 2014 (14:05 IST)   at Adelaide

Sri Lanka tour of India, 2014

Nov 6, 2014 (13:30 IST)   at Ahmedabad


West Indies tour of India, 2014

Nov 15, 2014  at Ahmedabad

Match cancelled

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Nov 7, 2014  at Bengaluru

Match cancelled

West Indies tour of India, 2014

Oct 30, 2014  at Hyderabad

Match cancelled

South Africa tour of New Zealand, 2014

Oct 27, 2014  at Hamilton

No result

Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh, 2014

Oct 25, 2014  at Dhaka

Bangladesh won by 3 wkts


Pakistan vs Australia, 2nd Test


Tendulkar provides teaser on upcoming book

Pakistan vs Australia 2014: Younis Khan’s double ton puts Pakistan on top against Australia at stumps on Day 2 of 2nd Test

Duleep Trophy 2014-15 final: Central Zone 214/4 at stumps; lead by 111 runs

Yuvraj Singh — have we seen the last of the man who won India three World Cups?

Younis Khan continues piling up records for Pakistan

KL Rahul could be opening option for India’s tour to Australia

Australia Australia tour of UAE 2014 Australia vs Pakistan Australia vs Pakistan 2014 Central Zone Duleep Trophy Duleep Trophy 2014-15 India Pakistan Pakistan vs Australia Pakistan vs Australia 2014 South Zone South Zone vs Central Zone Sri Lanka Sri Lanka tour of India 2014

WICB officials should visit India to minimize damage: Andy Roberts

Younis Khan: I want to be remembered as team-man

ICC World Cup 2015: New Zealand prime minister urges Indian fans to attend the tournament

Mohammad Yousuf: Muttiah Muralitharan would not have been allowed to bowl under current ICC rules

Mohammad Azharuddin’s son included in UP One-Day squad for Vijay Hazare Trophy

Don Bradman dismissed twice on the same day

Virat Kohli’s captaincy opportunities important in context of India’s succession plans

Rohit Sharma looks to strengthen career after an inconsistent year

Younis Khan equals Javed Miandad’s record of most 150+ scores by Pakistan batsman

India vs Sri Lanka 2014: Manish Pandey showing signs of fulfilling potential

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

678 Posts | 6 Fans

Video Highlights: Younis Khan century during Pakistan vs Australia 1st Test at Dubai

India A vs Sri Lanka: Fringe players look to impress

NGOs pursue education for all

Dance Basanti from Ungli: Put on your dancing shoes and practice the Basanti move!

Weight Loss Tip #59: Eat oranges to lose weight

Sensex surges 150 points in early trade to regain 27,000-mark

PricewaterhouseCoopers partners Google to offer business solutions to clients

Google X Lab working on nanoparticles to help detect diseases early

Priyanka Chopra has the best no make-up selfie on Instagram, think fans!

Lisa Haydon: I slept off midway while watching the original Shaukeen!

International programme in Animal Husbandry

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here