Home > Features >

Murali Kartik’s controversial action perfectly justified; time to relook at the rules

Murali Kartik © AFP
Murali Kartik has been criticised severely for ‘breaching the spirit of the game’ © AFP (File photo)

H Natarajan defends under-fire Murali Kartik and reasons out why the Mankading rule needs to be changed.

I have met Murali Kartik just once, but have interacted many times with him on phone, email and Whatsapp. To me, Kartik has always come across as intelligent, articulate and one who has a sense of fairness and balance in what he says and does. He is also very respectful.

Kartik has been under lot of fire for Mankading Bengal’s Sandipan Das in a Ranji Trophy game at New Delhi’s Jamia Milia Ground on Sunday. A lot of people have lampooned Kartik for ‘breaching the spirit of the game’. For me, the spirit of the game is always paramount, but in this case I fully support Kartik’s action. The reason is quite simple: Kartik had twice warned Das, but the batsman chose to ignore both warnings and continued to take unfair advantage. He asked for it.

Kartik is a fiercely-competitive cricketer — he had Mankaded a batsman in similar circumstances in a county game last year,  but he is not unfair. In my book, the Bengal team contravened the spirit of the game by refusing to shake hands with the Railways team after the game. Instead, they should have shown the displeasure, if not anger, against Das for frittering away his wicket in such a senseless manner.

If we are talking of rules, Kartik was more than a gentleman as the rules does not require him to warn the non-striker. But he gave not one, but two warnings.

Bengal coach Ashok Malhotra told the media at the end of the day’s play: “I can understand if you are playing one-day cricket where a batsman tries to steal a single. This is a four-day game and he was just an inch out. I am not talking about rules, but about spirit of the game.”

My counter to that is: Will Bengal not run out a batsman out if he is even one centimeter out even though he is not trying to take a single? Of course they will! Remember how Krishnamachari Srikkanth was run out on his debut against England when he casually left the sanctity of the crease?

The word “Mankaded” was coined during India’s tour of Australia. On December 13, 1947, during the second Test at Sydney, the great Vinoo Mankad ran out non-striker Bill Brown who was out of the crease before the bowler had delivered the ball. What is not known so widely is the fact that it was the second time Mankad had dismissed Brown in this fashion on the tour, having done it in an earlier match against an Australian XI. On that occasion he had warned Brown once before running him out.

Expectedly, many Aussies accused Mankad of lacking sportsman spirit, but there were some — including the legendary Don Bradman — who defended Mankad. In fact, Bill Brown reportedly said that he deserved what he got. This was revealed by Vinoo Mankad’s son Rahul in an exclusive video chat with CricketCountry.

Why should a batsman gain an unfair advantage? A bowler is penalised for no-ball even if he oversteps by a centimeter, a batsman is stumped/run out even if his foot is fractionally out of the crease. Are they given prior warnings? So why give the non-striker this special treatment? It makes no sense at all. I think the time has come for the rule about Mankading to be rewritten. Professionals should know what is right and what is wrong and do not need warnings. Had the rule been in place, the controversy would not have germinated in the first place.

(H Natarajan, formerly All India Deputy Sports Editor of the Indian Express and Senior Editor with Cricinfo/Wisden, is the Executive Editor of CricketCountry.com. A prolific writer, he has written for many of the biggest newspapers, magazines and websites all over the world. A great believer in the power of social media, he can be followed on Facebook athttp://www.facebook.com/H.Natarajan  and on Twitter at http://twitter.com/#!/hnatarajan)

Bangladesh Tour of West Indies, 2014

Aug 20, 2014 (18:30 IST)   at St George's, Grenada

South Africa in Zimbabwe, 2014

Aug 21, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Bulawayo

Bangladesh Tour of West Indies, 2014

Aug 22, 2014 (19:00 IST)   at St George's, Grenada

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 23, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Hambantota

India tour of England 2014

Aug 25, 2014 (15:00 IST)   at Bristol

More

South Africa in Zimbabwe, 2014

Aug 19, 2014  at Bulawayo

South Africa won by 61 runs

South Africa in Zimbabwe, 2014

Aug 17, 2014  at Bulawayo

South Africa won by 93 runs

India tour of England 2014

Aug 15, 2014  at London

England won by an innings and 244 runs

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 14, 2014  at Colombo

Sri Lanka won by 105 runs

South Africa in Zimbabwe, 2014

Aug 9, 2014  at Harare

South Africa won by 9 wkts

Photos

Highlights of Mahela Jayawardene’s Test career

Videos

Hughes explains technique behind cut shot

West Indies vs Bangladesh Live Cricket Score, 1st ODI at St George’s: Anamul Haque reaches his ton

Len Pascoe: There was a hospital ward named after Thomson and me

India tour of Australia 2014-15: 5 ways India can avoid another overseas embarrassment

MS Dhoni can benefit from borrowing the ‘Sourav Ganguly School of leadership’

Ravi Shastri inspired confidence as player and captain: Will he do it in a coaching capacity?

England England vs India England vs India 2014 India India tour of England 2014 India vs England India vs England 2014 Pakistan Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka 2014 Pakistan vs Sri Lanka Pakistan vs Sri Lanka 2014 Sri Lanka Sri Lanka vs Pakistan Sri Lanka vs Pakistan 2014

Singapore Cricket Club hosts International T20 tournament featuring Cricket Club of India among others

Mohammad Aamer to make acting debut in a Pakistan film

ICC Women’s Championship builds excitement

Kapil Dev is an opportunist, says Hockey India secretary Narinder Batra

Anamul Haque reaches his half-century

Len Pascoe: There was a hospital ward named after Thomson and me

India tour of Australia 2014-15: 5 ways India can avoid another overseas embarrassment

MS Dhoni can benefit from borrowing the ‘Sourav Ganguly School of leadership’

Ravi Shastri inspired confidence as player and captain: Will he do it in a coaching capacity?

Bernard Tancred: Best batsman of the first South African side

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

659 Posts | 6 Fans

India tour of England 2014: Sunil Gavaskar says Indian batsmen did not learn anything

Aamir Khan: PK is my favourite film till date!

Department of Telecom may come out with policy structure this fiscal

ICC Women’s Championship builds excitement

Illness with Ebola-like symptoms kills several in Congo: Locals

5 reasons to eliminate gluten from your diet

Kashmiri separatists meeting Pakistani leaders is an `old tradition`: Vaidik

Mohammad Aamer to make acting debut in a Pakistan film

After Riteish Deshmukh, Sidharth Malhotra completes the ALS ice bucket challenge – Watch video!

Connect Broadband launches virus control system

Barcelona to lodge appeal with CAS after FIFA upholds transfer ban

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here