Home > Features >

Shane Warne’s condemnation of umpire Aleem Dar quite unfair

Shane Warne's condemnation of umpire Aleem Dar quite unfair

Shane Warne (L) and Aleem Dar have had many on-field tiffs in the Tests they’ve been involved in. Aleem Dar’s on-field personality has always been strong and firm; perhaps Shane Warne the superstar didn’t take kindly to that? © Getty Images

By Hamza Ahmed Khan

For any Test match lover, last week has been heaven’s prototype model. Tests pitting Australia against South Africa, India against England, Sri Lanka against New Zealand and Bangladesh against the West Indies; for the third time in cricket history, four Test matches were played on a single day (Sunday).

Shane Warne was in India, commentating on the Mumbai Test for Star Sports. The on-field umpires Tony Hill and Aleem Dar had a bad game. They made some bad decisions spread out over Friday to Monday.

Here’s what Shane Warne tweeted, after the game culminated in England’s victory:

Shane Warne's condemnation of umpire Aleem Dar quite unfair

 
It is interesting to note that of the four games, the Decision Review System (DRS) facility was available only for the Test match being played in Australia. DRS permits each team to make two unsuccessful referrals to the third umpire for every innings. Cricket boards of Bangladesh and Sri Lanka usually opt out citing cost overruns.

The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI), however, opts out on arrogance. Yes they do present a reason for their stance against the DRS, but frankly it makes absolutely no sense.

Aleem Dar, before the awards of 2012 in which he was highly tipped to win by the way, has won three consecutive ‘Umpire of the Year” awards in 2009, 2010 and 2011. If Shane Warne’s comments were deemed to be true, for a start it would say more about the lack of competence of the rest of the umpires in ICC’s Elite Panel, rather than Aleem Dar.

One must question what prompted Shane Warne to make such a controversial statement, without solid backing. People have suggested it is a brilliant publicity stunt, though given Warne’s already famous persona, I find it a little hard to believe.

It is also a known fact that Shane Warne and Aleem Dar have had many tiffs in the past in Test matches they’ve been involved in. Aleem Dar’s on-field personality has always been strong and firm – perhaps Shane Warne the superstar didn’t take kindly to that?

Don’t forget that Warne is already notorious for post-retirement outbursts against colleagues and officials he did not like; case in point would be Adam Gilchrist and Australian coach John Buchanan.

When discussing a modern day umpire’s performance, it should be taken into account that the human brain remains one of the greatest examples of adaptation, and displays both its advantages and disadvantages. Before the technology of replays was introduced, the public never knew whether a decision was good or bad. After the advent of replays, we were able to judge better a decision given by an on-field umpire. For run-outs, after the introduction of third umpires, better decisions were made on close run-out calls.

Did it automatically grade earlier umpires who had made close run-out errors bad?

Similarly, with the introduction of the DRS, a lot of umpires have become bolder in giving decisions of doubt. An umpire’s mind has become more relaxed, with the knowledge that the batsman itself is able to prevent a howler by referring a decision. My point being, that most umpires’ minds have adapted to the comfort of the DRS.

It is the ICC’s prerogative to ensure members comply with the DRS requirements to keep the standard of umpiring consistent. Even the public viewing it has become comfortable with it. Hence, in the absence of the DRS, the howlers made by umpires are likely to be accentuated and publicised more, than a howler that is prevented through the DRS.

The best examples I can give are the two bad decisions given by Billy Bowden on the final day of the Australia vs South Africa Test on Tuesday. In the first session, Faf Du Plessis, the South African debutant was given an out in the 66th and 68th over of the innings.

In one of the decisions, an LBW had been given when the ball hadn’t even hit the pad!

Du Plessis used the DRS to reverse both decisions. Without the DRS, Faf Du Plessis wouldn’t have written his name into cricketing folklore by playing a match-saving innings of a lifetime! And all hell would have broken loose on Billy Bowden.

I think we would all agree that Aleem Dar has been below par in the Test series being played in India, especially given the high standards he has set for himself. But to call him a poor decision-maker and a poor umpire on the basis of a single series is grossly unfair, and what is eerily worrisome is that Warne chose a game involving India to make this statement.

Would the statement have been the same had Warne not been in India for the game?

After all, he’s commentated before in games involving Aleem Dar. I can’t imagine Warne being so vocal on umpires while commentating for Sky Sports in England.

Perhaps he recognised and utilised the opportunity of a public more receptive to his thoughts against a Pakistani, to vent a long borne frustration?

(The above article is from The Express Tribune and is reproduced with permission. A risk consultant by profession, cricket-crazed human by heart and a wanderer by choice, Hamza breathes cricket)

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 6, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Galle

India tour of England 2014

Aug 7, 2014 (15:30 IST)   at Manchester

South Africa in Zimbabwe, 2014

Aug 9, 2014 (13:30 IST)   at Harare

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 14, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Colombo

India tour of England 2014

Aug 15, 2014 (15:30 IST)   at London

More

India tour of England 2014

Jul 27, 2014  at Southampton

England won by 266 runs

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 24, 2014  at Bulawayo

Afghanistan won by 100 runs

South Africa tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Jul 24, 2014  at Colombo

Match drawn

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 22, 2014  at Bulawayo

Afghanistan won by 2 wkts

Afghanistan tour of Zimbabwe, 2014

Jul 20, 2014  at Bulawayo

Zimbabwe won by 8 wkts

Photos

India vs England 2014, 3rd Test

Videos

Highlights of Phil Hughes' double ton

India vs England 2014, 3rd Test at Southampton: Highlights

India vs England 2014, 3rd Test at Southampton: Reasons for India’s heavy defeat

10 little known facts about Jacques Kallis

Moeen Ali spins India into trouble: Will he stun them again on Day 5 at Southampton?

Jacques Kallis retires from international cricket: How an Indian fan remembers the South African legend

England England vs India England vs India 2014 Ian Bell India India tour of England 2014 India vs England India vs England 2014 Moeen Ali South Africa South Africa tour of Sri Lanka 2014 Sri Lanka

India vs England 2014, 3rd Test at Southampton: Sunil Gavaskar slams India’s abject surrender

Chris Gayle’s quick-fire innings takes Jamaica Tallawahs to victory over Antigua Hawksbills in CPL 2014

Jacques Kallis: I would love to play another season in IPL

Ajinkya Rahane, Moeen Ali make rapid strikes in ICC Test rankings

Revealed: How Sachin Tendulkar was nominated for Bharat Ratna in matter of just 5 hours!

India vs England 2014, 4th Test at Old Trafford: Ajinkya Rahane needs to play decisive role

Faisal Iqbal: Political interference has caused harm to my international career

Ray Markham — The Press Box Scorer who made it from the Loft to Lord’s

10 little-known facts about Sir Frank Worrell

Statistical analysis of Jacques Kallis’s ODI career

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

658 Posts | 6 Fans

Sachin Tendulkar's nine dismissals against James Anderson

India vs England 2014, 3rd Test at Southampton: Sunil Gavaskar slams India’s abject surrender

Watch Mary Kom song Ziddi Dil: Priyanka Chopra’s inspiring struggle to be a boxer!

Chris Gayle’s quick-fire innings takes Jamaica Tallawahs to victory over Antigua Hawksbills in CPL 2014

After Aamir Khan, Hrithik Roshan to go nude for a poster?

Rafael to miss rest of Man Utd’s tour of the USA with groin injury

Telecom Regulator Authority of India to hold seminar on mobile apps offering telecom services

Bitter acrimony against Team Rahul Gandhi in Goa Congress

Prevent Diabetes Tip – get regular health check-ups

Samsung Galaxy Alpha specifications leaked ahead of launch on August 13

Priyanka Chopra, Katrina Kaif or Deepika Padukone: Which B-town beauty should be immortalised?

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here