Home > Features >

Supreme Court hearing on IPL spot-fixing: Points that could work in favour of N Srinivasan

N Srinivasan © IANS
N Srinivasan is under tremendous pressure to resign as the BCCI president © IANS

By Deepak Chari

In the last couple of days, a lot has been written about, spoken about and ‘expert’ views have been voiced on the social media about Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) President N Srinivasan after the Supreme Court (SC) bench made certain observations. Former players, former BCCI chiefs and even some current members of the board have voiced their “strong” views as did cricket fans across cyberspace. A website also ran a “poll” where one could vote on whether Srinivasan should resign or not.

What is missing from the reams of newsprint and sound bytes is the legal aspects of the case. Hardly any journalist bothered to delve into this aspect of the matter. This is a case before the top most court of the country. This is an attempt to look at the legal aspects of the case, on a day when the Court resumed hearing and presumably give its ruling. At the outset, these are not the views of a qualified lawyer but thoughts stemming from accumulated knowledge, if one could term it that, from the experience of years of dealing with legal cases in a Corporate Finance environment.

Firstly, what is the legal sanctity of oral observations made by judges during the hearing of the case? Unless these observations find a place in the final order that is passed, they have no legal sanction. In a court hearing, when lawyers of both sides are arguing, the judges pose questions, make comments (sometimes sarcastic) and express opinions contrary to what the lawyer is arguing about. When the judgment is finally passed, many of the conversations, even expressed opinions of the judges, do not figure in the Order that is passed.

Secondly, the case before the SC is for doing a proper probe on the betting and match-fixing issue. The petitioner, one of the members of this private body [BCCI], complained that the earlier probe was improper and inconsistent with the body’s rules and was not impartial. So the SC asked for a different person to conduct the probe. This person [Justice Mudgal] has found some merit that the Bihar member’s allegation cannot be dismissed and has submitted a report. By law, the SC can ask for a police or CBI investigation and prescribe that the report be given to them. Unless such a report indicts and proves that the BCCI President was guilty, there is no question of a private body’s duly elected official to resign on moral grounds. Moral grounds are only applicable to “public officials” as defined, and BCCI is not one of those. This being election season, readers will recall how the SC-appointed a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to probe into the allegation of government connivance during the Gujarat riots and asked the SIT to report directly to the SC. That SIT gave a clean chit to the Gujarat CM. Therefore, legally one can take the stand that just as an elected CM did not resign when allegations were thrown (in a case which involved loss of life, as compared to this case where the loss is only that of money   and alleged activities that were against the law of the land – activities that are legal in some other countries by earlier probes and he was finally absolved by the SIT appointed by the SC, so too an elected President of a private body does not have to resign and can wait for a probe by SIT.

Thirdly, in the conduct and composition of BCCI, it varies substantially from the structure of India. For example, some states of the Union do not have membership at all whereas some states have multiple memberships. The BCCI operations and activities do not get any financial subsidy from the Indian government. So how can it be anything but a private body? And if it settled law that Bangalore Club can have its own rules for memberships or even a dress code that is at variance, then by the same premise BCCI’s officials do not have to be answerable to public and resign on moral grounds.

Full coverage of Supreme Court hearing on IPL 2013 spot-fixing and betting scandal

Fourthly, the SC held recently that Lalit Modi cannot be barred from standing for or being elected or holding office as Rajasthan CA’s President against the BCCI even though he was a ‘proclaimed offender’ for some tax law violations by the Govt. of India. How then can the same SC order that BCCI President should resign when he is not been proven guilty or even had charges filed against him for a criminal or civil offence?

Fifthly, this is to the disadvantage of BCCI. The BCCI is registered as an Association of Persons under the Societies Act in Tamil Nadu. The case filed against Srinivasan by AC Muthiah, former BCCI President, has already established that. Under that Act, there have been instances where the Courts have ordered the appointment of administrators where it has found that the elected management were guilty of mismanagement and illegally siphoned off the members monies. Perhaps the lawyers of the Bihar Cricket Association could take this plea and argue in Court on today.

We are set for an interesting day in Supreme Court indeed. The Court’s website could well have more hits than on sports and social media websites today!

(Deepak Chari is a cricket enthusiast who had the unique distinction of umpiring on both sides of the pitch in the quarterfinal of the state senior schools championship even though he was a member of his school team which played and lost that match. Nowadays, he demonstrates that trait by taking contrarian views. When not doing that, he works as the CFO of a Bangalore-based technology company) 

India tour of England 2014

Aug 30, 2014 (15:00 IST)   at Nottingham

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 31, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Harare

India tour of England 2014

Sep 2, 2014 (15:00 IST)   at Birmingham

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Sep 2, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Harare

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Sep 4, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Harare

More

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 30, 2014  at Dambulla

SL won by 7 wkts (D/L method)

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 29, 2014  at Harare

South Africa won by 61 runs

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 27, 2014  at Harare

South Africa won by 7 wkts

Bangladesh Tour of West Indies, 2014

Aug 27, 2014  at Basseterre, St Kitts

No result

India tour of England 2014

Aug 27, 2014  at Cardiff

India won by 133 runs

Photos

Aaron Finch's record 156 vs England in T20I

Videos

Alastair Cook looks ahead to 3rd ODI at Nottingham

MS Dhoni records most stumpings in international cricket during India-England 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge

India vs England Live Cricket Score 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: Ajinkya Rahane guides India

Give Virat Kohli a break, India

India vs England 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: Why India will miss Rohit Sharma

MS Dhoni’s statistics at No 5 and 6 in ODIs are phenomenal

Australia England England vs India England vs India 2014 India India tour of England 2014 India vs England India vs England 2014 Pakistan Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka 2014 Pakistan vs Sri Lanka Pakistan vs Sri Lanka 2014 South Africa Sri Lanka Sri Lanka vs Pakistan Sri Lanka vs Pakistan 2014 Zimbabwe Triangular Series 2014

India vs England, 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: India looking good after early wicket

India vs England 2014, 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: Shikhar Dhawan dismissed by Chris Woakes

Hyderabad post 403/6 against TNCA President’s XI in Buchi Babu

James Anderson booed by Indian fans at Trent Bridge in 3rd ODI between India and England

Doug Bollinger might be recalled for Pakistan Test series in UAE

Sri Lanka vs Pakistan 2014 3rd ODI at Dambulla: Highlights

MS Dhoni records most stumpings in international cricket during India-England 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge

Give Virat Kohli a break, India

India vs England 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: Why India will miss Rohit Sharma

India vs England 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: India’s likely XI

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

667 Posts | 6 Fans

10 Most Unbeatable Records in Cricket

Ebola infected monkeys said to be recovering with ZMapp

Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa 7 eliminated contestant Kritika Kamra’s online accounts get hacked!

This is the only Apple iPhone 6 leak video you should watch ahead of September 9 launch

International programme in Animal Husbandry

Hyderabad post 403/6 against TNCA President’s XI in Buchi Babu

India vs England 2014, 3rd ODI at Trent Bridge: Shikhar Dhawan dismissed by Chris Woakes

India vs England 3rd ODI: India off to steady start; Score 24/0 in 5 overs at Nottingham

HTC to finally unveil two wearables, Desire 820 with 64-bit processor at IFA on September 4

Norms to blacklist weapon manufacturing firms eased partially

Priyanka Chopra: I can’t go bald for a film just for one or two scenes

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here