Home > Features > Moments in history >

Time wasting by West Indies and an incredible umpiring howler deny India a famous win

Time wasting by the West Indies and an incredible umpiring howler deny India a famous win

Vijay Hazare (batting) © Getty Images

On February 8, 1949 India were set 361 in their fourth innings for what would have been their first Test victory. Abhishek Mukherjee looks back at a thrilling day’s cricket where Rusi Modi, Vijay Hazare and Dattu Phadkar decided to chase the impossible.

Amarnath decides to go for it

A target of 361 is never easy to chase. It was almost unthinkable in 1948-49, more so because India had never won a Test before that. However, in the third Test at Calcutta, they were set 431 for a victory, and they had responded superbly with 325 for three in the fourth innings. Additionally, they had fought bravely after following on to save the first two Tests.

So they had decided to chase. But all went wrong at the very beginning. In the third ball of the second over Gerry Gomez produced an absolute beauty; the inswinging yorker went through KC Ibrahim’s defense and bent his leg-stump. His partner, the cavalier Mushtaq Ali (who almost ran out Rusi Modi) on-drove Prior Jones for four; but in Jones’ very next over, Mushtaq attempted a feeble late cut, and Clyde Walcott took the resultant snick. India were nine for two.

Lala Amarnath, the Indian captain, was fuming in the dressing-room. He wanted India to throw a challenge to the West Indian bowlers. When Probir Sen, the Indian wicket-keeper, had dislocated his shoulder on the first day, Amarnath had kept wickets for both West Indian innings: he probably needed some rest before stumps. But such was his fury that he promoted himself in the batting-order and walked out amidst a huge ovation from the Bombay crowd – a ground where he had created history about two decades back.

Modi could only be a spectator, mostly providing the strike to his captain on a consistent basis. Amarnath vented out his fury on the West Indian attack. His counter-attacking 39 put the Indian chase right back on track. He unsettled the bowlers, and Modi provided him with the necessary support.

Soon, Modi on-drove Gomez for a three, and Amarnath followed suit with an all-run four amidst great cheer from the crowd. Modi once again on-drove Gomez for a two, and brought up the 50 in 65 minutes. The chase was on. As news got out, the crowd started pouring in, and within no time crossed the 30,000-mark.

The Jones bowled one short and Amarnath upper-cut him over slips – a shot that has later been made famous by Sachin Tendulkar and Virender Sehwag – for four runs. John Trim and Denis Atkinson were brought on. Amarnath responded immediately by a cover-drive that went to the boundary – to borrow a cliché from Ravi Shastri – like a “tracer bullet”. He followed it by an elegant late cut off Trim that rushed to the fence. Then Atkinson produced a beauty that came in to hit his off-stump, and that was that. The partnership had yielded 72 runs in 72 minutes.

Everyone expected a night-watchman to walk out, but Amarnath, having decided on wasting no time, asked Vijay Hazare to join Modi. India were 90 for three at stumps, and an exciting day’s cricket was on the cards.

What happened earlier

West Indies had been bowled out for 286 – their first sub-300 score on the tour – thanks to some hostile bowling from Dattu Phadkar and a crafty, miserly spell from Vinoo Mankad. Jeffrey Stollmeyer and Everton Weekes had contributed with fifties. The Indians were then skittled out for 193, all four bowlers sharing the wickets: Modi and Hazare, who added 72 for the third wicket, put up some fight with a 72-run third wicket partnership. Sen did not bat.

Then Shute Banerjee came into the scene, bowling out West Indies for 267, taking four wickets on his debut and five in the match; Allan Rae fought with a gallant 97. It turned out to be Banerjee’s only Test. Mankad, once again, played a brilliant supporting act and finished with three wickets in each innings. The target was 361.

The final day

Modi and Hazare had already put up three 100-run partnerships in the series: 156 in the second Test at Bombay and 129 and 108 at Calcutta. Additionally, they had added 64 at Madras, and had battled it out in the first innings here. Now they were determined to produce an encore. It did not matter that Modi was running a temperature. They knew they had to do it to level the series.

On the final day, India required 271 in 300 minutes. The duo began in a spectacular fashion. Jones and Gomez were immaculate with their precision, but Modi and Hazare still managed to keep the scoreboard ticking. The first 30 minutes yielded 34, and it was then John Goddard decided to fall back to a defensive field: as he brought on Cameron, he sent nearly everyone to the fence. But Hazare still managed to find the gaps: he first drove Cameron over his head for a four, and then, with a packed off-side field, square-cut him for another boundary. They had already gone past 150 in 172 minutes, and Modi had crossed his fifty.

Goddard brought himself on now. He had a packed off-side field with two slips, a gully, a third man, a deep point, a short cover and an extra-cover, along with a mid-on and a long-on. This meant that there were acres of space in the leg-side, but Goddard was bowling way outside the off-stump, and from the other end Gomez was very difficult to score off. It was then that Ghulam Ahmed ran out with a message from the captain: the batsmen immediately resorted to quick singles that would have put batsmen of later years to envy. The frantic efforts of the athletic West Indian fielders to run them out all went in vain.

The clock still caught up with the score, and now India needed to score 200 from 200 minutes. Gomez, who had bowled unchanged till just before lunch, was relieved after a spell of 17-3-24-0 despite the aggressive intent of the Indians. Hazare then late cut Jones for a four to bring up his 50 in 118 minutes: India reached lunch with 175 for three, Modi on 66 and Hazare on 54. They needed 186 more from two sessions.

After lunch Modi and Hazare began attacking yet again. Runs came thick and fast, and Goddard shuffled his bowlers around. Hazare soon became the first Indian to reach 1,000 Test runs. Goddard, not the greatest of brains, was pushed by Gomez and to take to leg-theory, keeping two men behind square on the leg-side, a long-on, a mid-on, a mid-wicket, and one more – six fielders in all. Hazare and Modi tried to counter this by taking guard outside the leg-stump, and finally Modi perished in pursuit of quick runs. He had scored 86, and the pair had put up their fourth 100-partnership of the series – this time 139 from 172 minutes. Hazare was on 78 now.

Mankad walked out. From the very beginning it was obvious that Mankad would provide the strike to Hazare, who would keep the onslaught on. Hazare rushed to his 100 in no time (in three and a half hours, with only 10 fours – which probably shows how well he ran with Modi; Modi had hit only four boundaries in his 86), and then hit three consecutive boundaries off Trim. The third of these was a fearsome square-cut – and the Bombay crowd was on its feet. The 250 came up in 295 minutes. Then, Jones came back and managed to take Mankad’s edge: Hazare and Mankad had added 55, of which Mankad had scored only 15, including a delicate late cut for a four.

At this stage Jones bowled too many bouncers to slow down the Indian scoring rate, and was at the receiving end of some serious barracking from the crowd. The barracking reached a stage where Jones refused to bowl unless the crowd went quiet when he began his run-up; the crowd, realising that invaluable time was being wasted, decided to keep quiet.

Amarnath promoted Phadkar over Hemu Adhikari – a specialist batsman – at this juncture. Phadkar was known for his strokeplay, and Hazare thought India still stood with a chance. It was then that a length ball from Goddard rose sharply and hit Hazare on, in his own words, “the lower part of my anatomy”.

Hazare sought medical help. Five valuable minutes were lost; worse, before Hazare could regain composure, Phadkar called him for a sharp single that brought back the pain. A somewhat unsettled Hazare was bowled by Jones for 122. He had scored 560 in the series – 26 short of Modi’s 586, which now stood as the Indian record. India now needed 76, and when the last hour’s play began, they needed 72.

Phadkar takes over

Phadkar, one of the most underrated all-rounders in the history of Indian cricket, now took the burden on his broad shoulders. Even a well-spread West Indian field could not contain him. Banerjee was promoted above Adhikari; he hit a six, but was promptly bowled by Jones. Adhikari walked out at 303 for 7.

At 321, Adhikari perished as well, to give Jones his fifth wicket of the innings. As Ghulam Ahmed walked out, India still required 40 to win, and with Sen unlikely to bat, this was their last wicket. However, Goddard, instead of going for the kill, decided to secure his 1-0 lead and contain Phadkar. The Indians, too, being under the impression that losing the series 0-2 hardly made it worse from losing it 0-1, decided to hit out.

As Goddard had spread his field wide, Phadkar could not find the boundaries, but the pair ran hard, converting ones into twos and twos into threes, and suddenly the target seemed achievable. The West Indians panicked. Twenty one runs were needed from 15 minutes now. With the allowance of one drinks break per session, Goddard called for drinks to kill some time.

Even after the drinks break, Phadkar and Ghulam Ahmed did not stop. When a ball went to deep fine-leg, Walcott himself ran at a leisurely pace with his pads on to collect the ball! A few more minutes were wasted. Even then, Phadkar slashed one off Goddard hard and edged it for a four. Ghulam Ahmed then attempted a slog and got four byes. As the clock ticked over, India reached 350 from 361 minutes, and required only 11 now – with a maximum of two possible overs.

Jones ran in now. He knew it was going to be his final over, and he decided to give it all. He bowled one outside leg-stump, and no run could be scored – 11 needed off 11.

Jones bowled a short one – once again on the leg. Phadkar was prepared for it. He quickly moved to the leg and square-cut it hard. The shot sounded like the crack of a whip, and the sparse off-side field could not stop the boundary – seven needed off 10.

Jones bowled on the pads again. Phadkar decided to risk a single and give the strike to Ghulam – six needed off nine.

One stroke could do it now. Ghulam Ahmed, going for the slog, did not time it, and only managed to push the ball to the leg-side, but the batsmen decided against the single – six needed off eight.

Jones steamed in. He let loose a bouncer that went high above the batsman’s head. Ghulam Ahmed now needed to survive one more ball, and with a minute and a half left, Phadkar should surely pull it off for India in the final over.

It was then that umpire Bapu Joshi came into play. He had miscounted the number of balls, and had called “over”. And, to make things worse, he was possibly carried away by the excitement and removed the bails to call it stumps! It was an anticlimax of the worst possible sort. A bemused Phadkar walked back with Ghulam Ahmed, and India were deprived of their first-ever Test win, thanks to the negative tactics of the West Indians and an incredible display of irresponsibility by umpire Joshi.

The jubilant West Indians rushed to collect the stumps as souvenirs; it was heartbreak, though, for Amarnath, Modi, Hazare and Phadkar, all of whom had batted brilliantly. West Indies claimed the series with that victory, but the series, without a doubt, marked India’s entry into the world of cricket with their supreme batting efforts in four of the five Tests.

Brief scores:  West Indies 286 (Jeffrey Stollmeyer 85, Everton Weekes 56; Dattu Phadkar 4 for 74) and 267 (Allan Rae 97; Shute Banerjee 4 for 54) drew with India 193 and 355 for 8 (Vijay Hazare 122, Rusi Modi 86; Prior Jones 5 for 85).

(A hippopotomonstrosesquippedaliophobiac by his own admission, Abhishek Mukherjee is a statistical analyst based in Kolkata, India. He typically looks upon life as a journey involving two components – cricket and literature – not necessarily as disjoint elements. A passionate follower of the history of the game with an insatiable appetite for trivia and anecdotes, he has also a rather steady love affair with the incredible assortment of numbers the sport has to offer. He also thinks he can bowl decent leg-breaks and googlies in street cricket, and blogs at http://ovshake.blogspot.in)

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 29, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Harare

India tour of England 2014

Aug 30, 2014 (15:00 IST)   at Nottingham

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 30, 2014 (10:00 IST)   at Dambulla

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 31, 2014 (13:00 IST)   at Harare

India tour of England 2014

Sep 2, 2014 (15:00 IST)   at Birmingham


Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 27, 2014  at Harare

South Africa won by 7 wkts

Bangladesh Tour of West Indies, 2014

Aug 27, 2014  at Basseterre, St Kitts

No result

India tour of England 2014

Aug 27, 2014  at Cardiff

India won by 133 runs

Pakistan tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Aug 26, 2014  at Hambantota

Sri Lanka won by 77 runs

Zimbabwe Triangular Series, 2014

Aug 25, 2014  at Harare

Australia won by 198 runs


Don Bradman's ducks


Mitchell Marsh: This is a big opportunity for me

MS Dhoni did not cross the line, clarifies BCCI secretary Sanjay Patel

Suresh Raina: Ravi Shastri gave us a lot of confidence

Adam Gilchrist ‘apologises’ to Glenn McGrath on Twitter

Michael Hussey calls for stringent measures to prevent illegal bowling actions

MS Dhoni heaps praise on Suresh Raina for match-winning knock

Australia Australia and South Africa in Zimbabwe 2014 England England vs India England vs India 2014 India India tour of England 2014 India vs England India vs England 2014 Pakistan South Africa Sri Lanka Sri Lanka vs Pakistan Sri Lanka vs Pakistan 2014 Zimbabwe Zimbabwe Triangular Series 2014

Sri Lanka vs Pakistan 2014: Kashmiri students bashed up in Punjab for supporting Pakistan

ICC World Cup 2015: David Richardson satisfied with preparations

Suresh Raina: Batting with MS Dhoni helped me

England fined for maintaining slow over-rate in 2nd ODI

MS Dhoni did not cross the line, clarifies BCCI secretary Sanjay Patel

Aaron Finch rapidly emerging as Australia’s key batsman

Ravindra Jadeja: India’s go-to man against England in ODIs

Indian team discusses victory over England in 2nd ODI on Facebook

AB de Villiers, Faf du Plessis and other instances of two batsmen scoring centuries in a chase of over 300

India vs England 2nd ODI stats highlights

Fan of the Day

Niharika Shah

Niharika Shah

664 Posts | 6 Fans

Funny cricket video

Spain’s Xabi Alonso bids goodbye to International football

Sex Tip #34 – Heat things up with lingerie!

Amitabh Bachchan dances with Deepika Padukone and Arjun Kapoor to ‘Bootiya’

ICC World Cup 2015: David Richardson satisfied with preparations

Now, a smartphone app that detects jaundice in babies

Why did people stop showing interest in Aamir Khan’s films?

NGOs pursue education for all

Xiaomi to sell 40,000 Redmi 1S units on September 2, over 100,000 have already registered

Sri Lanka vs Pakistan 2014: Kashmiri students bashed up in Punjab for supporting Pakistan

Kaun Banega Crorepati 8: Amitabh Bachchan charms Parineeti Chopra – View pics!

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here