Home > Features > Facts and figures >

Why MS Dhoni needs to test England with a three-pronged spin attack

Why MS Dhoni needs to test England with a three-pronged spin attack

Ravichandran Ashwin (left) and Pragyan Ojha (right) are certain to lead the Indian spin attack, but there are compelling numbers to suggest that a third spinner would bring about greater potency to the Indian attack © Getty Images

 

Indian strategy to use spin to overcome the Englishmen is clear from the voices doing rounds as well as the selection of the teams for tour matches. Arunabha Sengupta analyses figures and wonders whether it is prudent to go for a three spinner approach during the series. 

— 

 

There are talks of revenge echoing loud and clear from all corners.

 

The prevailing thought is to do unto others as others have done unto us. Rank turners are in vogue, as fitting response for green pitches on which we were tortured to despair. Established pillars of the team as well as rank newcomers have all voiced the same sentiments. And the comments have been met with mixed reactions.

 

On one side there are arguments that emphatically want to cash in on home advantage with a predominantly spin attack on tailor-made tracks for them. These are people that live for the moment, without a care about the long-run damage by such a lop-sided approach. They feel that looking towards the distant future at the cost of the immediate present is downright stupid. 

A few months earlier the Australians and Englishmen were beating us black and blue with conditions carefully tailored to suit the best of their bowlers. Were they in any way looking at preparing spinning pitches for their batsmen to be nurtured in view of some distant tour of the subcontinent? Is there any side in the world that does not benefit from home advantage? Besides, who said Test cricket should be played only on fast bouncy tracks and turners need to be relegated to second or third class status?

 

There are pros and cons that can be discussed for eternity, and like any cricketing issue in fan-space, no concrete conclusion will ever be reached.

 

However, it is a fact that most teams have thrived under home advantage. And Indian cricket did turn a crucial corner from the 1990s by exploiting the weakness of visiting teams against turning deliveries on surfaces where the first ball on the pitch results in puffs of dust.

 

And with the India A side selected without any spinner, the strategy of the Indian think tank is very obvious. Spin is the mantra that will cast spells around the visitors, and extract our desired pound of flesh.

 

The question that crops up is: If India is going all out for decimation with spin, does it make sense to play three spinners? Or, instead, do we stick to Ravichandran Ashwin and Pragyan Ojha and play two pace bowlers – one for reversing it as the ball gets older and the other to add glamour to the fine leg area?

 

Turning figures

 

If we look at the turning point of Indian home Test record, it started in the days of Mohammad Azharuddin. He usually steadfastly stuck to Anil Kumble, Venkatpathy Raju and Rajesh Chauhan as his three-pronged spin attack. On rare occasions the off-spinner’s role taken up by Ashish Kapoor or Nikhil Chopra

 

The results were more than good. He won 11 of the 16 matches played with three spinners since 1993, and lost just two. On the other hand, when he switched to the two spinner policy, he won, lost and drew one Test match apiece.

 

But then, Azharuddin was helped for long by the presence of pace-bowling all-rounders, initially Kapil Dev and then Manoj Prabhakar, whose batting prowess enabled an extra slot for a spinner. However, since 1999, the formula changed to two pacemen, two spinners and six batsmen – three spinners taking the field very rarely. The role of the third spinner was performed with a lot of gusto, and some success, by the likes of Sachin Tendulkar, Virender Sehwag and, more recently, Yuvraj Singh and Suresh Raina.

 

Let us look at the numbers to find out which approach has been more successful.

 

In the following table we take a look at the performance of the team with two and three spinners in the side since the England tour of 1992-93.

 

It also includes the only Test match at Mohali in 2005 when India for some reason went in with Anil Kumble as the sole spinner, and could not dislodge the last five Pakistan wickets on the final day to force a win.

 

To ensure unbiased inference, we have also removed the matches against the minnows during this period.

 

Spinners played by India in Tests since 1993-93 and the associated results:

 

(excluding Tests against minnows)

 

Spinners

Tests

Wins

Draws

Losses

%Wins

%Draws

%Losses

W/L Ratio

3

26

17

6

3

65.38%

23.08%

11.54%

5.66

2

56

24

21

11

42.86%

37.50%

19.64%

2.17

1

1

0

1

0

0.00%

100.00%

0.00%

-

Total

83

41

28

14

49.40%

33.73%

16.87%

2.93

 

The numbers do speak very eloquently about the merits of the three-spinner approach. The win-loss ratio comes down from 5.66 to 2.17 when the combination changes from three spinners to two.

 

Lest one infers that this is skewed due to the dust bowls of the 1990s, let us note that even after 2000, the three spinner ploy has served the side well whenever used.

 

Playing three spinners has brought the series-clinching victory in Chennai against Australia in 2001, and has also allowed India to win against England at Mohali in 2006 – the final time such a team structure was used. Since 2000, India has won three, and drawn and lost one Test apiece while playing three tweakers simultaneously.

 

True, Yuvraj picked up five wickets for India A, but depending on his bowling to win Tests for India is far from the ideal strategy, especially given all that he is been through in the past year.

 

England had loaded their team with four fast men while trouncing India on the fast, seaming surfaces at home. And now, one can feel their tremors at the mere mention of spin.

 

The moment seems rather opportune for a third spinner in the form of Amit Mishra, or even Harbhajan Singh, to join forces with Ojha and Ashwin with a few opening overs entrusted to Virat Kohli.

(Arunabha Sengupta is a cricket historian and Chief Cricket Writer at CricketCountry. He writes about the history and the romance of the game, punctuated often by opinions about modern day cricket, while his post-graduate degree in statistics peeps through in occasional analytical pieces. The author of three novels, he can be followed on Twitter at http://twitter.com/senantix)

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Dec 17, 2014 (14:00 IST)   at Centurion

India tour of Australia, 2014-15

Dec 17, 2014 (05:29 IST)   at Woolloongabba, Brisbane

West Indies in South Africa, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (14:00 IST)   at Port Elizabeth

Sri Lanka tour of New Zealand, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (03:30 IST)   at Christchurch

India tour of Australia, 2014-15

Dec 26, 2014 (05:00 IST)   at Melbourne

More

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 19, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

New Zealand won by 68 runs

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 17, 2014  at Abu Dhabi

New Zealand won by 7 runs

England tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Dec 16, 2014  at Colombo

Sri Lanka won by 87 runs

Pakistan vs New Zealand in UAE, 2014

Dec 14, 2014  at Sharjah

Pakistan won by 147 runs

England tour of Sri Lanka, 2014

Dec 13, 2014  at Pallekele

Sri Lanka won by 90 runs

Photos

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane

Videos

Josh Hazlewood looks back at his 5-wicket haul

India vs Australia 2014-15, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: India 157 for 7 at Lunch, lead by 60

Pakistan vs New Zealand, 5th ODI at Abu Dhabi: Key clashes

Live Cricket Score, South Africa vs West Indies,1st Test, Day 3 at Centurion: Samuels and Chanderpaul rebuild for West Indies

Pakistan vs New Zealand 2014, 5th ODI at Abu Dhabi Preview: Teams prepare for high-octane finale

Anil Kumble Australia India Ishant Sharma Moments in history Ravichandran Ashwin Ricky Ponting South Africa

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Shikhar Dhawan dismissed for 81

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 4: Shikhar Dhawan scores fighting half-century

India vs Australia 2014-15, 2nd Test at Brisbane: Team India complains about practice pitches as Shikhar Dhawan is injured before play

Steve Harmison unhappy with ECB’s timing to sack Alastair Cook as England ODI skipper

Mitchell Johnson reduces India to 157/7 against Australia at lunch on Day 4 of 2nd Test at Brisbane

New Zealand vs Pakistan, 5th ODI at Abu Dhabi: Marks out of 10 for Kiwis

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane: India’s tail tales

India vs Australia, 2nd Test at Brisbane: India’s tail ought to take leaf out of Australian tail’s book

India vs Australia 2nd Test at Brisbane, Day 3: India’s pathetic bowling performance, Mitchell Johnson’s onslaught and other highlights

India’s inability to dismiss Australia’s tail can have huge impact

Fan of the Day

Suraj Gowda

Suraj Gowda

653 Posts | 10 Fans

India vs Australia: Murali Vijay's 144, Video highlights

प्रसिद्ध कथक नृत्यांगना सितारा देवी नहीं रही

More broadband connections to boost GDP growth in Asia Pacific: GSMA

India is becoming our largest overseas market, Xiaomi CEO Lei Jun says

Bigg Boss 8: Ali Quli Mirza, Renee Dhyani, Upen Patel, Praneet Bhatt, Sonali Raut – who should be evicted this week?

Revealed: The reason why Kishore Kumar’s biopic starring Ranbir Kapoor won’t feature Katrina Kaif!

अभिनेत्री प्रियंका चोपड़ा ने स्वच्छ भारत अभियान में हिस्सा लिया

Also on cricketcountry.com

Play Fantasy Cricket & Win

Cash Daily! Click here