MS Dhoni is the most successful Indian captain on several statistical counts

On Tuesday, after the crushing victory over Australia, MS Dhoni became India’s most successful Test captain. Arunabha Sengupta looks at the numbers to reveal that he leads the tables on several counts, across formats of the game.

---

As Ravichandran Ashwin’s full and straight delivery went past James Pattinson’s tentative bat and thudded into the pads, Mahendra Singh Dhoni became the most successful Indian captain in Test cricket.
The record took close to half a decade and 45 Tests to arrive. In spite of the crushing setbacks of the past couple of years, the landmark has been achieved with the best win-loss ratio among all Indian captains who have led in five or more Test matches.

Characteristically, the Indian captain underplayed the importance of the milestone. But it does not make it any less significant.

It is quite an achievement for someone harnessed with a team in transition for quite some time now. For all those who harped about Dhoni capitalising on a team built by others, it must be pointed out that for the last couple of years he has had to deal with the constant bother of retirement, aging stars, run-less opening batsmen and unproductive bowlers. If he had started his reign on a crest, he has been thoroughly tested by the trough, and he has indeed come out with flying colours.

What makes Dhoni’s achievements even more incredible is that only one of the 22 wins under his leadership have come against a minnow. He has never led against Zimbabwe and only once against Bangladesh.

In contrast, Sourav Ganguly, the previous holder of the record, led 11 of his 49 Test matches against Zimbabwe and Bangladesh, and was indebted to them for as many as nine of the victories.

Indian captains	T	W	L	W-L Ratio
MS Dhoni	45	22	12	1.83
SC Ganguly	49	21	13	1.61
R Dravid	25	8	6	1.33
SM Gavaskar	47	9	8	1.12
M Azharuddin	47	14	14	1.00

If we discard the minnows from the equation — removing Zimbabwe and Bangladesh for all captains and Sri Lanka for Sunil Gavaskar’s period — Dhoni’s record loses little sheen, while the same cannot be said for all.

Indian captains against major sides	T	W	L	W-L Ratio
MS Dhoni	44	21	12	1.75
R Dravid	23	7	6	1.16
SM Gavaskar	46	9	8	1.12
M Azharuddin	44	13	13	1.00
SC Ganguly	38	12	12	1.00

While the recent reverses in England and Australia are still fresh in our memories, we often tend to forget that Dhoni is one of the few Indian skippers to have led the side to overseas series wins twice. Only Ajit Wadekar and Rahul Dravid have managed this feat before him.

India’s overseas series wins (other than in Zimbabwe and Bangladesh)

Captain	Year	Opponent
MAK Pataudi	1967-68	New Zealand
Ajit Wadekar	1970-71	West Indies
Ajit Wadekar	1971	England
KapilDev	1986	England
M Azharuddin	1993	Sri Lanka
Rahul Dravid (2 Tests)  + Sourav Ganguly (1 Test)	2003-04	Pakistan
Rahul Dravid	2006	West Indies
Rahul Dravid	2007	England
MS Dhoni	2008-09	New Zealand
MS Dhoni	2011	West Indies

 

While the long-serving captains in Indian cricket has been predominantly batsmen, MS Dhoni manages to hold his own against them with the willow — in spite of his additional role of a wicketkeeper. His batting record as a captain is exceptional, behind only Sachin Tendulkar and Sunil Gavaskar. Surprisingly, he has a better batting average as a skipper than Rahul Dravid and Mohammad Azharuddin.
 

Batting performance as captain	T	Runs	Ave	100s
SR Tendulkar	25	2054	51.35	7
SM Gavaskar	47	3449	50.72	11
MS Dhoni	45	2729	44.73	5
R Dravid	25	1736	44.51	4
M Azharuddin	47	2856	43.93	9
SC Ganguly	49	2561	37.66	5
MAK Pataudi	40	2424	34.14	5

The success in Test cricket is accompanied by a fantastic record in the One-Day Internationals (ODIs) as well. Having led India to the World Cup triumph in 2011, he still has some distance to cover to overtake Mohammad Azharuddin as the most successful captain in ODIs. But, even here Dhoni has a win-loss ratio way ahead of the others.

Indian ODI captains	M	W	L	Win-Loss Ratio
MS Dhoni	135	77	45	1.63
R Dravid	79	42	33	1.27
M Azharuddin	174	90	76	1.18
Kapil Dev	74	39	33	1.18
SC Ganguly	146	76	65	1.16

As in Test cricket, Dhoni’s record remains impressive even when we take the minnows out of the equation. In fact, once minnows (Zimbabwe and Bangladesh for modern skippers and Sri Lanka for Kapil Dev) are removed, only MS Dhoni and Rahul Dravid end up with more wins than losses.

ODI’s against Major sides	M	W	L	Win-Loss Ratio
MS Dhoni	125	68	46	1.47
R Dravid	71	35	32	1.09
M Azharuddin	150	70	73	0.95
KapilDev	57	25	31	0.80
SC Ganguly	110	45	60	0.75

Where Dhoni still has some miles to go is in the race for number of tournament wins. The World Cup was indeed a glorious feather in his cap, but if we consider all tournaments featuring three or more sides, Azharuddin is quite some distance ahead.
 
 
ODI Tournament wins of India

Captains	Number of Wins	Tournament	Year
M Azharuddin	9	Asia Cup	1991
		Hero Cup	1993
		Singer	1994
		Wills World Series	1994
		Asia Cup	1995
		Independence Cup	1998
		Coca-Cola Cup	1998
		Coca-Cola Traingular	1998
		Champions Trophy	1998
MS Dhoni	4	CB Series	2008
		Compaq Cup	2009
		Asia Cup	2010
		World Cup	2011
KapilDev	2	World Cup	1983
		Rothman's Cup	1985
SM Gavaskar	1	Benson Hedges	1985
RJ Shastri	1	Sharjah Cup	1988
DB Vengsarkar	1	Asia Cup	1988
SR Tendulkar	1	Titan Cup	1996
SC Ganguly	1	NatWestTrophy	2002

 


(Arunabha Sengupta is a cricket historian and Chief Cricket Writer at CricketCountry. He writes about the history and the romance of the game, punctuated often by opinions about modern day cricket, while his post-graduate degree in statistics peeps through in occasional analytical pieces. The author of three novels, he can be followed on Twitter at http://twitter.com/senantix)