Suresh Raina (left) and Virat Kohli © Getty Images
Suresh Raina (left) and Virat Kohli © Getty Images


By Benjamin Prabhu


Gautam Gambhir follows close friend and Delhi team-mate Virender Sehwag, with injury concerns of his own, which may just make him sit out of the West Indies tour and deprive him of the opportunity to further his credentials as India captain. This would most likely pave way for Suresh Raina to get a second shot at captaincy after a poor first stint in Zimbabwe a couple of years ago, highlighted by two defeats to Zimbabwe and failure to qualify for the tri-series final.


My question is: Should it be that straight forward? It’s no secret that Virat Kohli has been earmarked for captaincy for quite a while now. He has prior experience, having led the India U-19 team to World Cup glory, and has stepped in admirably for Daniel Vettori as skipper of Royal Challengers Bangalore in this year’s IPL. He has grown into a mature and well-rounded cricketer in the last couple of years, with high praises from the people who matter. You will be hard-pressed to find anybody who disagrees that he should be groomed as the future Indian captain.


Yet, by a quirk of fate, Raina is one step ahead of him. Having made his debut for India much before Kohli, he also has the advantage of having played Test matches. So, the selectors have used logic in placing Raina in proper hierarchy, ahead of Kohli in the captaincy stakes.


Personally, I wish the selectors would be bold enough to make Kohli the skipper if Gambhir is ruled out of the series. Yes, that would be unfair to Raina, as he has not done anything to make his case weak and has an impressive resume. Paralysed by doubt and insecurity during the Greg Chappell era, he made his way back into the Indian team through sheer determination and is one of the few batsmen to have scored centuries in all three formats of the game, and was crucial in India’s victories in the quarters and semis of the recent World Cup. When a wicket falls, he is the first fielder to rush either the bowler or fielder (whoever is closer!) with a fierce hug. He is never short of ideas in the field, involving himself in decisions of bowling changes or field placements. I suppose if Kohli was not around, he would be the unanimous choice for the much sought-after position in Indian cricket.


My only grouse is that Raina is not established in either Tests or ODIs right now. After a thrilling start to his Test career, he has tapered off, losing his position to Cheteshwar Pujara in the process. In the ODIs, he was not even in the first choice playing XI during the league stages of the World Cup, playing his first game of the tournament in the quarterfinal against Australia. (It reminds me of the way Mahendra Singh Dhoni got his shot at captaincy. With Virender Sehwag and Yuvraj Singh having fitness/form issues, Dhoni grabbed the opportunity to establish himself as the long-term option; and India have not looked back since then.) Raina should be spending the major part of the coming season, in developing himself as a quality Test player and making himself as a permanent fixture in the ODI team as well. While Kohli may not have made his Test debut yet, no one doubts that it is just a matter of time now. This is the perfect time to assess Kohli the captain, in an ODI series against the West Indies.


In the short run, it might not matter as Dhoni isn’t going anywhere and Gambhir will take over when Dhoni is unavailable; but it will be nice to have a clearer idea of who the future Indian captain might be. Suresh Raina or Virat Kohli: what’s your choice?

(The writings of Benjamin Prabhu (Benny, aka tracer007) are products of a fanatical cricketing mind for over a decade and a half. After a brief stint in school cricket in the 90s, he decided that chasing a red ball around a field in white flannels as a substitute fielder was not really getting him anywhere. He subsequently entered medical school, where he spent half the time learning how not to kill a patient and the rest of the time, sharing his opinions about the state of international cricket to people who had no idea of what he was talking about. Since graduation, he is living in the US, where he chanced upon the world of cricket blogging; and in an instant, an idea to start a cricket blog shot through his brain ‘like a tracer bullet’ and (likeatracerbullet) was born)